📂 Tuesday, September 19, 1995 — Day 157
◀ Criminal Trial
📅 Tuesday, September 19, 1995 31 proceedings 2250 lines
Address:
C:\DEPT103\CRIMINAL\1995\SEP\19
TRIAL
▲ Day 157 of 167

Day 157 — Tuesday, September 19, 1995

Defense Challenges Vannatter Suspect Status Claims; Fiatos Testify
Judge Lance A. Ito • Criminal Trial • 31 proceedings • 2250 lines
tense

The defense recalled Detective Vannatter and presented Larry and Craig Fiato and FBI Agent Michael Wacks to challenge Vannatter's testimony that Simpson was not a suspect when detectives went to Rockingham. Larry Fiato testified that Vannatter said Simpson was a suspect; Craig Fiato described only a general remark that 'the husband is always the suspect'; and Wacks said he heard a suspect-related remark but did not hear Simpson's name or Rockingham and could not recall the exact words. Vannatter denied making the statement and maintained that Simpson became a suspect only after the glove discovery. The court granted a protective order for the Fiato witnesses, and the defense argued to recall FBI Agent Martz and call Dr. Frederic Whitehurst to challenge Martz's EDTA methodology and alleged pro-prosecution bias.

  • Judge Ito grants defense motion to recall Detective Vannatter for impeachment based on Fiato statements
  • FBI Agent Michael Wacks testifies he overheard Vannatter say words to the effect that they went to a house because a man was a suspect, while acknowledging he did not hear Simpson's name or Rockingham and could not recall the exact words
  • Larry Fiato testifies Vannatter said Simpson was a suspect in two separate conversations (hotel and courthouse)
  • Craig Fiato hedges his prior statements, characterizing Vannatter's remark as general rather than Simpson-specific
  • Court grants protective order excluding cameras and sketch artists during Fiato testimony (FBI-protected organized crime informants)
  • Court hears arguments on the defense request to recall FBI Agent Martz and call Dr. Frederic Whitehurst regarding EDTA methodology, record-keeping, and alleged pro-prosecution bias
Day 157 • 31 proceedings • 2250 lines
Criminal Trial
Department 103
📂 Day 157 — SEP 19, 1995
SEP 19, 1995