📂 Tuesday, March 21, 1995 — Day 42
◀ Criminal Trial
📅 Tuesday, March 21, 1995 24 proceedings 2550 lines
Address:
C:\DEPT103\CRIMINAL\1995\MAR\21
TRIAL
▲ Day 42 of 167

Day 42 — Tuesday, March 21, 1995

Shapiro Dismantles Detective Vannatter's Credibility on Evidence Handling
Judge Lance A. Ito • Criminal Trial • 24 proceedings • 2550 lines
devastating

Shapiro conducted a devastating cross-examination of Detective Vannatter, methodically exposing critical failures in evidence handling, documentation, and the accuracy of his search warrant affidavit. Key problems emerged including the Rockingham glove appearing in no detective's notes, an unrefrigerated blood sample transported on a car seat for two hours, and the defense argument that handwritten notes showed no blood was found on the socks on June 13, with blood detected only during phenol testing weeks later. Darden's redirect attempts could not fully rehabilitate the detective, and the day ended with Kato Kaelin beginning his testimony.

  • Vannatter cross-examination reveals Rockingham glove appears in none of four detectives' notes or chronological records
  • Blood sample handling exposed: unrefrigerated, transported on car seat for nearly two hours without documentation
  • Defense challenges socks evidence, arguing handwritten notes showed no blood was found on June 13th and that blood was detected only through phenol testing weeks later
  • Search warrant affidavit confirmed to contain two false or premature statements under oath by Vannatter
  • Shapiro's dramatic moment showing his own bruised hand to establish injury context, prompting judge agreement it was 'absurd'
  • Crime scene documentation questioned: photographs showed a bed strap in different positions, and Vannatter did not know why it had been moved
  • Detective Lange recalled to confirm both south-side Rockingham doors were locked on June 13th morning
  • Kato Kaelin begins direct examination, establishing his relationship with Simpson and Nicole Brown Simpson
Day 42 • 24 proceedings • 2550 lines
Criminal Trial
Department 103
📂 Day 42 — MAR 21, 1995
MAR 21, 1995