📂 Tuesday, November 19, 1996 — Day 18
◀ Civil Trial
📅 Tuesday, November 19, 1996 25 proceedings 3243 lines
Address:
C:\DEPT103\CIVIL\1996\NOV\19
TRIAL
▲ Day 18 of 57

Day 18 — Tuesday, November 19, 1996

Nicole's Fear Recorded; Kaelin Faces Sustained Credibility Challenge
Judge Hiroshi Fujisaki • Civil Trial • 25 proceedings • 3243 lines
tense

The day combined emotional evidence from the 1993 tape with extensive testimony and credibility disputes surrounding Brian Kaelin. Exhibit 757 played Nicole Brown's recorded statement expressing fear of Simpson's ‘animalistic look,’ and the court heard evidence about items recovered from her safe deposit box. Kaelin described the McDonald's trip, the thumps, a duffel bag, and Simpson's cut finger; Baker challenged his timing and later-emerging details, while Petrocelli used phone records, prior testimony, and Kaelin's rejected story offers to rehabilitate him.

  • Audio Exhibit 757 played featuring Nicole Brown's voice expressing fear of Simpson's 'animalistic look' during 1993 domestic disturbance call
  • Michael Stevens testifies that the safe-deposit-box search recovered photographs (Exhibits 8 and 9) and a sealed envelope containing Nicole Brown Simpson's will; Exhibits 8, 9, and 2196 are later admitted without objection
  • Brian Kaelin testifies about June 12 evening: McDonald's run, mysterious thumps at Rockingham around 10:40-10:50 PM, and blood on Simpson's finger
  • Defense challenges Kaelin's timing accounts, including his estimate for the thumps, while redirect compares his 9:40-9:45 McDonald's return estimate with a 9:37 regular-phone record
  • Baker reveals Kaelin pursued book deals in late 1994 before detailed testimony crystallized, suggesting memory reconstruction rather than recall
  • On redirect, Kaelin says he turned down $500,000-$1,000,000 in story offers and that Baker's team never contacted him; Baker separately portrays him as aligned with the plaintiffs
  • Defense objects to the Lally tape on foundational and hearsay grounds; Baker later tries to introduce Officer Tippin's employment by Petrocelli's firm, but the objection is sustained
Day 18 • 25 proceedings • 3243 lines
Civil Trial
Department 103
📂 Day 18 — NOV 19, 1996
NOV 19, 1996