Detailed entries (12)
Technical exhibits used in Gerald Richards's testimony and related photography-expert questioning included film-scratch and frame-alignment enlargements, an underexposed contact sheet, Frame 0 demonstration materials, perspective illustrations, a shoe-sole reflection photograph, and a chart of Groden's claimed alteration points. Plaintiffs' 2290 depicted an open Canon F1 camera, and a later source records the admission of photography exhibits Plaintiffs' 2357-2373.
Thirty photographs taken by E.J. Flammer at Rich Stadium on September 26, 1993, showing O.J. Simpson in group and individual shots at a Buffalo Bills event. During the civil trial, the photographs were offered as additional images purportedly showing Simpson in Bruno Magli-style shoes; Robert Groden testified that they did not change his opinion about the Scull photograph's authenticity.
Contact sheets, negative strips, and a C-41 negative associated with Harry Scull's September 26, 1993 photographs, including the questioned frame and surrounding images. The materials were examined during disputes over alignment and authenticity, and the C-41 negative was described as having been sent to Gamma-Liaison in London for scanning.
Photograph taken by Harry Scull at Rich Stadium on September 26, 1993, showing O.J. Simpson full-length, including his feet; trial participants described it as purportedly showing Bruno Magli shoes. Scull's photograph was published in the National Enquirer on April 23, 1996, and defense counsel challenged its authenticity.
Marked photographs and corresponding blow-ups identified as Plaintiffs' 2071, Plaintiffs' 2072, Plaintiffs' 2076, Plaintiffs' 2287, Plaintiffs' 2288, Plaintiffs' 2289, and Plaintiffs' 2357. They were used to compare blue lines across frames, examine claimed retouching and halo effects, and display an enlargement of the photograph identified in the source as Exhibit 1830.
A 12-slide series used during Robert Groden's testimony about claimed anomalies in the questioned negative. The sources identify annotated images concerning an asserted second or “false” edge below Frame 1, blue-line issues across frames, and horizontal and vertical lines in Frame 1-1.
Original negatives and contact sheets from E.J. Flammer's two rolls of film, including group and individual photographs of Simpson and Bills warmup images. The negatives were described as being held by the court, and Flammer consented to leaving them for defense examination; an expert also examined the negatives, proof sheets, and enlargements for signs of alteration.
Comparison boards containing enlargements and contact prints derived from the Scull photograph, including a laboratory recreation used by footwear examiner William Bodziak in comparing shoe characteristics with the Bruno Magli Lorenzo pattern. In later testimony, Bodziak said the Flammer photographs showed the same class characteristics as the shoes in the Scull photograph.
Photographic blow-ups used in testimony about Groden's claim of retouching or cloning in Simpson's left-leg and pants area, together with a copy of plaintiffs' exhibit 1932 marked by Groden and a zoomed view used in questioning about heel position. Gelblum challenged the retouching claim during cross-examination.
Exhibit 1918 is a waist-up photograph of Simpson interviewing Keith Byers, showing the same tie, shirt, and jacket referenced in the questioning. Exhibit 1916 shows Simpson standing before the game in the same jacket, tie, shirt, and pants as the end-zone photograph, while the shoes remained disputed; Defendants' 1921 shows Simpson holding a microphone and was used for color-balance comparison.
Negative 7A was identified as the source of a black-and-white photograph published in the November 1993 Buffalo Bills Report. A color print from the same frame was displayed as Plaintiffs' 2329 during the civil trial.
Videotape footage showing O.J. Simpson at the same September 26, 1993 Bills game wearing the same jacket, tie, and pants as depicted in the disputed Scull photograph, played in open court to corroborate the authenticity of the still photograph.
Additional references (3)
Brief references from transcripts that don't warrant an individual page. Each has a single source or is mentioned only in passing.
- Groden post-deposition demonstrative slides and diagrams — Post-deposition slides and diagrams created by defense expert Robert Groden for demonstrative purposes in the civil trial, which were disputed by opposing counsel at the close of the proceeding, with Gelblum objecting to their use and Judge Fujisaki deferring the question to lunch-break discussion between counsel.
- Photograph Allegedly Showing Simpson in the “Killing Shoes” — A photograph that Kelly described in closing argument as showing Simpson wearing the alleged “killing shoes” and said Simpson had called a fake.
- Photograph Used to Analyze Harry Scull's Camera Handling — A photograph used by a photography expert to analyze how Harry Scull loaded and pointed his camera.