Petrocelli conducts a wide-ranging examination of Cora Fischman, Nicole Simpson's closest friend, covering Nicole's relationships after leaving OJ (Alessandro, Keith, Marcus Allen, and several others), the 1993 reconciliation and its ground rules, OJ's persistent jealousy and his conversations with Cora about Nicole. The session also reveals that Nicole called Cora's boyfriend [Name Deleted] at 2 a.m. on June 12 — the morning of her murder — asking whether Cora was there and relaying that Cora should go home because her children were looking for her and Ron was angry. Nicole and [Name Deleted] then spoke for approximately an hour later that morning, when Nicole reportedly said that he should leave Cora alone for a while.
I don't mean conversations yesterday. I mean any conversation about the deposition, about getting ready for the deposition, to prepare for the deposition.
Now, yesterday you had said to us that you paid no attention to the subpoena. Now, I asked you to go back and review all of your files, records and documents and anything else that you might have in response to the subpoena. Have you done so?
I looked-I tried to look for the Brooke Skulski book notes, and I couldn't find that, so - and the picture that you told me, I couldn't- you know, see, the picture that you told me about OJ., I gave that to Shapiro and to Marcia Clark, so I couldn't find it.
But I don't have pictures, you know- Nicole and I, our picture together was just my birthday party. I mean, we didn't take a lot of pictures of ourselves, so...
You can object, but, you know, I am still entitled to the information. It's a discovery process, and he may have relevant information concerning these murders, and I intend to ask him.
Excuse me [Name Deleted]'s last name and address are not, you k now, highly sensitive information. He is an ordinary person, like the rest of us, whose name and address may appear in hundreds of different materials and documents. I don't understand why this is so sensitive.
Well, the sensitivity is the concern that this deposition will be disseminated again and the press is going to harass [Name Deleted]. When we took the deposition of Kim Goldman, you were sensitive about her friends, and we wrote down addresses and their names. I don't understand the difference.
Before I decide whether or not to instruct her one way or another, and I will make that determination, I wanted to see whether there was a different way to go about it that might accomplish-might satisfy my needs.
If there is some way that she can give you this information without it being part of the transcript, and if that is-and I'm not privy to whatever accommodations or measures you've taken in the past to ensure that security measure, that privacy measure, but I would like to see if we could explore that.
Okay. Well, what we'll do, without waiving any right whatsoever known to mankind concerning this, is agree to let her write it on a piece of paper, name and address and telephone number.
Petrocelli points out that Cora failed to mention Nicole's 2 a.m. phone call to [Name Deleted] during the prior day's session, despite being asked about her contact with Nicole on June 11-12. Cora's defense — 'You didn't ask me' — is noted but Petrocelli treats it as a significant gap.
She apparently wanted to know if I was there, and I told [Name Deleted], "Tell her I'm not here, because I don't want to go home." And so Nicole apparently said, "Tell her to go home because her kids are looking for her and Ron is angry. Ron's been calling." So that's pretty much the conversation.
Key quote
Describes the 2 a.m. phone call on June 12 — the last night of Nicole's life — and the ordinary domestic concerns Nicole was expressing just hours before the murders.
-did you not feel any need to talk to Nicole the next morning to explain your whereabouts and to maybe quell any anxieties on her part as to where you were?
You know what? We were so busy with the recital, I figured we'd talk when we go for our run that Monday, because usually Monday we do our run, and I figured that would be the best time for us to talk.
Pretty much what they talked about the night before: That-that I should-that [Name Deleted] should leave me alone for a while, that Cora's marriage-let Cora take care of what she has to take care of, and pretty much she asked questions on how often I go to his house, and mainly they talked about the kids, and that's it.
No, that's not why. She felt guilty, because she said to [Name Deleted], "I feel guilty. I feel I'm the one who pushed Cora into having a relationship with you."
That is beautiful, but the point is you are invading this woman's privacy rights in an attempt to harass her. She has constitutional privacy rights which you are treading over in your diatribe to bring out as much rumor and gossip as you possibly can.
ExchangeDaniel Petrocelli · Phil Baker
Baker accuses Petrocelli of 'invading this woman's privacy rights in an attempt to harass her' when Petrocelli presses on how Nicole instigated Cora's affair; Petrocelli responds dryly: 'You are getting very good, Mr. Baker.' Baker: 'Thank you.'
I will be delving into this area in detail. It directly involves Nicole, and it's highly relevant to understanding this witness' relationship with Nicole and her bias. Thank you.
She told me to loosen up. She says, you know, "Cora, you have such a bad marriage. Why don't you just relax, and probably this will help your marriage in the long run."
Key quote
Nicole's advice to Cora to pursue an extramarital affair — which later puts Cora at [Name Deleted]'s home on the night of June 11-12, connecting the affair to Nicole's final known conversation with [Name Deleted].
Well, in the neighborhood, because [Name Deleted] used to play basketball at the park, and they've seen-not-they don't know, but [Name Deleted] knew her as being OJ.'s wife. Not personally. They didn't know each other personally.
And Nicole had been going to some therapy sessions and had experienced some self-growth and felt that there was a better chance of her relationship working. True?
Well, let's focus a little bit then on that time frame. You had many discussions with Nicole about her decision to go back to Mr. Simpson in April '93 and before. Correct?
Because she still loved OJ. At the time she was afraid that OJ. will be completely out of her life. She-and I told her, I said, "You make sure that if this is what you want this is what you want," because at the time OJ. was going out with Paula already, and she wanted her family back.
One was if only OJ. could be around the kids. He travels too much. He-he traveled, he works too much. If only they could have a simple life as opposed to all this, you know-
Well, when they went back-when they got back together, they both kinda talked to each other, saying that that will be over. Whatever happened the last seven years of their marriage, they're gonna work on that. That's why she was gonna clean up her act, and OJ., whatever he was doing, it was just going to be the two of them. They were going to make a commitment and it's just going to be the two of them. No more of these other men or other women.
Well, you know what? We didn't talk about that. We talked about how husbands get angry, you know, and we talked about how we said sometimes we'd push each other's button, because knowing-you know, that's pretty much our conversation.
But did Nicole discuss with you her concerns about whether she would run into problems with physical abuse or violence if she got back with OJ. Simpson?
And Nicole told you that one of the things that caused her to end her relationship or her marriage with OJ. Simpson was the beating she received in 1989. Correct?
No. She was just tired of everything already, the womanizing, the-pretty much everything. That's what she said. And also she already was having an affair with [Name Deleted]. She found this guy, and they had been going out.
To my knowledge? I don't know. When I-when we got really close, she already said it's been going on and she's thinking of moving in with this guy, so I'm not sure as to the time frame. It could be six months.
The anticipation? You know, I don't remember, because all I know is I told her, you know, "You can't go on with your affair if you're gonna live there. You have to move out and try to"-that's pretty much-I don't know the-I mean, because when we started talking, she already-when OJ. got back from New York, she spoke to OJ., and they-you know, she said, "I wanted out."
Even during the time - the whole time that they were trying to reconcile-I mean, they tried to reconcile, and even the time when he was trying to understand why she wanted to get out of the marriage.
Because Nicole made-because Nicole told me, "Don't ever, whatever happens, don't ever tell OJ. that I had an affair before I left Rockingham," and I-I made a promise to her.
Key quote
Establishes that Cora actively concealed Nicole's affair from OJ at Nicole's explicit request, and that she kept that secret even when OJ directly asked her.
Well, not moved in. As a guest, as a house guest, because at the time he was fix--he was trying to open up Mezzaluna in Brentwood, and he needed, you know, he needed a place and Nicole offered her guest house.
Refresh my memory, yeah. Okay. After Keith was [Name Deleted]. She was attracted to this guy, and so she asked Kris Jenner, she says, "I want to meet this guy," so that's how this whole thing was set up.
While Keith was still a house guest at Gretna Green, Nicole went to Cabo with Kris and [Name Deleted] and Faye, and Kris invited Nicole. She said, "[Name Deleted]'s gonna be there," and that's where they all went.
And to your knowledge OJ. Simpson at this point in time was still interested in getting Nicole back, as of the time Nicole sat down with him on Mother's Day?
But you understood form your conversations with Nicole that Mr. Simpson was still interested in putting the marriage back together for a period of time. Correct?
Well, he's trying to understand Nicole. He was trying to understand Nicole and what was- what does she really want, and I told-you know, I told him, "Just leave her alone. She needs some time to be alone. She needs to reassess her life," and pretty much, you know, said that, "She loves you. She loves you. She still wants the kids," words like that.
Well, he says you know "I love that woman." You know, "We had such a great marriage. What happened?"
Key quote
OJ's own words, relayed through Cora, expressing continued emotional attachment to Nicole during their separation — part of Petrocelli's effort to establish obsessive control.
Keith? Yeah, I asked. I asked him about that, and he said he saw them, and he said that-he says, you know, "I don't like what Nicole does because the kids are there." He says, "If she wants to do something like that, she should do it someplace, but not with the kids around."
Well, he just told me, but that's about-I didn't even know he was at the window. He told me that he saw, so I don't know-you know, to me probably you're right.
Yes, they were both interested in trying to work things out. See, Nicole didn't want a divorce. She just wanted a separation. OJ. wanted a divorce, and so-
Well, because, see, to him, if she wants to continue having men in her life, OJ. said, "Well, if that's what she wants, that's what she wants, and we get divorced." But, see, Nicole just wanted a separation because she just wanted to know what was going on in her life.
In between also, when she left- when she went to move to Gretna Green, that's when the relationship with Marcus Allen started. You know, whenever Marcus Allen was in town, she saw Marcus.
Around-it was around that tune when Nicole told-when Nicole told OJ. about the affair, so say April, May, June, because they were already playing golf already, and then Marcus' wedding took place at Rockingham.
Because she felt that if they were gonna start a life together, that they were gonna come clean both ways. No more womanizing, and she's not going to have any secrets or any men. If it's the two of them, it's just the two of them.
You know, the moving in, it's kinda -what they-the two of them talk about moving back together, and they say, "No. We love each other, but we cannot live together. I think it's better to have each other place," you know. So I don't know what kind of answer you want me to-
I don't remember. They both wanted to be together, but they could not find the time or-they seemed not ready to live in one house because they said that they don't want any more fighting, you know, because they said, you know, "You can't put the kids back and forth from one house and then separate." So they were just more concerned about the kids. Especially Nicole was concerned also about the kids, you know.
He said that, you know, "If we move back together, I will not"-"I will not allow this going out with the girls and going out dancing." That was one. And, you know, he says, "If we were committed to each other, that's it; we're committed to each other, but I will not tolerate the going out and going out with girls and coming back at 3:00, 4:00 o'clock in the morning?" That's what he said.
She says that they're going to try to make a commitment and that they're working on their relationship and that they're gonna try and-that's pretty much that's what it is. They're gonna try and work it out, see what happens.
No. Okay. Now, was there a period of time aftern they began to see one another in April of '93 that things were going well, based on your observations?
'93 was when they went to Cabo. They had a great time in Cabo, so- and then when he left, it started- Nicole started changing her mind, and she didn't want-
Well, they would plan on getting married the following year, and then they said no, they're really not ready to live together, but they could be together but not living together, so that's what I mean by off and on? But if they had a good relationship, I would say yes, they did.
I don't remember. You know, it's hard when you're running and you're just talking, it's-I don't remember but, yeah, we talked about that. Like sometimes she feels like it was too early for her to go back to OJ., like she's not really ready. She felt like she just wanted like another year. She said, "I came back to OJ. too early," but she was willing to work it out, you know.
Well, yeah. What I am trying to find out is, you're talking about when they would get back together as a husband and wife and live in the same home again. Right?
But was there a time in that year when Nicole told you or OJ. Simpson told you that they don't want to try it make it work anymore, that they want to stop it?
Oh, what he told me? He just wants to make sure that what Nicole is doing is-whatever she was doing is what she wants to do. That's pretty much it. He says, "Do you think she really is serious about that?"
I said, "Yeah," you know, "look what we're doing," you know, "we even taking" _ "playing"-you know, she never liked to play golf. We started taking golf lessons. You know, we did a lot of things. And at the time she was gonna move to wherever OJ. wanted her to move. That time they talked about Cabo San Lucas. You know, they found a place.
I don't know. But-so Nicole was excited about that because she said, "Oh, that's great. I'll just be in Cabo and sunbathe the whole"-you know, and Nicole wanted to move to wherever OJ. wanted to move, so...
But what made OJ. mad was when they were in-see, what Nicole told me and also what OJ. also told me was Nicole went to Rockingham and noticed the picture of Paula in the family room, and Nicole got mad at OJ. She said, "You said there won't be any more pictures. Why is there a picture of Paula here?. And Nicole got mad because the frame that was used was the frame of their wedding picture, and so Nicole was upset with that.
So she-they started fighting over that, and she went home, and OJ. went to her house, and they were already saying-you know, they were fighting. He says, "What's going on? You're telling me not to have pictures, and here you have pictures." And he says, "Look at you, look at all these pictures you have." You know, "Who's Keith?" And Marcus Allen, whatever. That's the time-and he was yelling. She went upstairs and called 911.
Yeah, she called me-no, she didn't tell me about that. I just realized that the 911 tape was when I was watching the video, you know, whatever the testifying.
Yeah, she told-he told me about the pictures, you know, they fought about pictures. He says, you know "I'm looking at the pictures. She's mad at the pictures, and I go to her house; they've got pictures"-"she's got pictures of all the men in her life, though." That's pretty much-
Did Nicole during her divorce proceedings with OJ. Simpson tell you that the divorce was-that she was going to settle the case rather than go to court? Did she discuss that with you?
She told me that she just wanted to end and that she wanted to have a life with [Name Deleted], and
[Name Deleted]has kinda told her that, you know, "Why don't you just settle, so that way we can buy a house." You know, because she was planning on living together with [Name Deleted] at that time.
Because she read this book about obsessive love and she thought it was interesting, and that she said, "Oh, my God, look at this," and so that's why she went and contacted the author.
Okay. Based on your knowledge and experience and your relationship with Nicole, if Nicole wrote down incidents of abuse, do you believe that they occurred?
That her sessions were boring and that her sessions were-she really didn't help her at all understand and that she couldn't afford it. That's pretty much what she told me.
But I told you the two. There were two-twice that we-that OJ. was there when we got there: One was Mezzaluna. I remember that was a Tuesday, and we were there, and OJ. walked in with a friend, and at that time Nicole-there were like a lot of guys sitting, and there was one guy sitting on her lap, and when OJ. walked in, he said to Nicole, "Is this what you wanted?" and all of a sudden, all the guys just left and-
Oh, God. We were waiting for our table. That was the opening night of that restaurant. We were waiting at the table-for our table, and it was crowded, and all of a sudden, you know, a few minuses after OJ. was there, and so Nicole goes, "Guess what? He's around."
Okay. Now, you gave a statement that Nicole was being followed by OJ. in late 1994 or-that is, in May or June of 1994 while she was doing her errands. Do you recall that?
Okay. Let me read your statement that you gave to [Name Deleted]
"We were at Toscana"- "this hairdresser . . . . at some point when we were. . . at Toscana the guy was there.. And he went crazy . . . " Does that refresh your recollection as to what you saw that evening at Toscana?
Cora, the question was, does that-the reading of that statement refresh your recollection of what happened that night and what you saw? Either it does or it doesn't. THE WITNESS: It doesn't.
Let me ask you a question: Is everything-when you were talking to Michael Viner and the gentlemen there from the media, was everything that you told them true to the best of your knowledge at that time?
And while we are on that topic, we have pre-marked exhibits 156, 157 and 158 and 159, which are all statements by you. Okay?
Exhibit 156 is an interview-is a summary of a statement that you gave to Detectives LeFall and A.J. Luper on June 14, 1994, and Exhibit 157 is a summary of a statement you gave to Detective Payne on June 24. The first statement, by the way, is June 14th.
Hold on just a second. That-I am going to make a distinction in the question, because I want to make sure the witness is clear. You're asking whether what she said at the time to the people was truthful-
Did she relate to you any other incidents during her time at Gretna Green when she thought OJ. Simpson was looking at her or spying on her or hiding in the bushes or anything like that other than the Keith Zlomsowitzh incident?
Well, we were gonna go for a run, and then she noticed that her key was missing. She said "Oh, my key is missing. I can't find it." So I said, "Okay, fine, we'll run," So- but that was the conversation that we had.
Well, because at the time OJ. was in and out of the house, too, because, see, OJ. was feeding-was helping -at that time OJ. was helping the kids, too, because he was there most of the time. They were trying to reconcile, too, at the time, so he was there.
Okay. Now, during the break you had a chance to review exhibits 156, 157, 158, which are all statements that you gave to police officers- actually, their reports of your statements.
And 159 is the Star Magazine article for which you were paid money. Let's talk about Exhibit 156, June 14 interview with Detectives LeFall and A. J. Luper. Are all the statements reported in Exhibit 156 accurate?
Thank you. Exhibit 158 is a report of your third interview with the police, this one with Detective Vannatter. That's on September 15th, 1994. Are the statements on Exhibit 158 accurate?
The witness is referring to the page 27 of the Star Magazine article, the description of the Kris and Bruce Jenner Christmas party in December of 1993?
First, she wanted a sensationalized book, and I said, "I don't want a sensationalized book."
She says, "Cora, you have to expose yourself. You've got to talk. Nobody knows you."
That's why I ended up doing that, because she said, "You've got to do something or else nobody"-no publisher will want your book because nobody knows who Cora Fischman is."
And I said no, and that's why I kept on refusing to-I hold onto that one-year contract with her, but I told her, "I'll just put the book on hold," because I didn't want a sensational book. She wanted a sensational book, and I said I wanted to humanize Nicole; I wanted people to know who Nicole was. That's all I was-that was my intention if I wanted to ever write a book.
One was because I was subpoenaed, so when you're subpoenaed in the criminal, you can't do anything; you can't talk about the case or anything like that. So that one. Number two, she was very opinionated, and the voice that was coming from her, I didn't like the tone of her voice. It was just too-she-it was more a tabloid, and I didn't want a sensationalized book. I wanted a book that would memorialize my friend. That's all I wanted.
Because of that picture. She is the one, you know, she said, you know, "We need pictures."
I said, "Well, what kind of pictures? I don't want"-and I said, "Okay, we'll take this picture. It's been in the National Enquirer, I said, "Yeah, my housekeeper stole that picture," and that's when the lawsuit came.
Yeah. But they didn't put it on the first page, but they put it on the inside page, see, because they couldn't do that because at that time National Enquirer put it on the front page.
No. The same week they had the same article. One was the Christmas story but with my picture on the National Enquirer. Whatever that family picture, National Enquirer put it on the front page and Star put it on the middle page.
Let's get beck to the chronology of events in 1993 to 1994. Okay? And I was asking you about whether Nicole and OJ. Simpson had ever had any big fights, and you told me you didn't know of any at the time; later on found out about the 911 call. Okay?
Now, was there any time at all going into early '94 leading up to Nicole's trip to Cabo that she told you that she did not think things were going to work out after all?
She said that-I don't know. It's -I think it was also-I think it was after Cabo. That was after the- that's when she decided that it's not gonna work out.
Because she said, "It's really not fair. OJ. and I, when we see each other, we get into each other and then he leaves," and then she said she gets lonely again, and she doesn't like that feeling. So she says, "I crave for him. I crave for him."
She messed around. And to your knowledge, now, this was the first time she had been with another man in over a year, since the time she decided to make things work with OJ. Simpson. Right?
Well, at that time she was also seeing Marcus Allen. See, Marcus Allen was at her house intermittently. You know, not all the time. But I told you whenever Nicole-whenever OJ. was out of town-
And so as far as you know, Nicole breached that understanding and that agreement when she started to see Marcus Allen when he would come into town when OJ. would go out of town. Right?
When Nicole would tell you that she would see Marcus, did she also tell you that she didn't want things to work out any longer with OJ. Simpson or that she was still going to try to do that?
When Nicole told you that she had messed around in Cabo with this guy named [Name Deleted], she also told you that at this point in time she didn't think things were going to work out with Mr. Simpson, right, and she was going to try to move on with her life?
Yes, before Cabo, because we went shopping. Yeah, March of 1994. Nicole and I were shopping for clothes at Brentwood Gardens, and these two guys kept following us, and one of the guys introduced herself-himself to Nicole, and that was [Name Deleted].
Mike-Nicole was very attracted to Michael, and she told me that she liked that guy.
"He's really cute." So that was-and she kind of pursued Michael, but Michael-when Michael found out that she was OJ.'s ex-wife, that's when, you know, she - you know, he stopped-kinda like backed off a little bit, but Nicole still continued pursuing [Name Deleted].
Okay. And, now, when Nicole was having this relationship with [Name Deleted], did you ask her what did this mean in terms of her relationship with OJ. Simpson, whether she was growing disenchanted with that relationship, why she was doing this?
Well, she said that she was getting old and that she-she says, you know, "Core, when we're 50 years old, nobody's gonna look at. Look at this." You know, she says-I think she was fascinated by young men being attracted to her. You know, she liked that feeling.
I would like to have-or have had marked during the break, I should say, the next exhibit in order, Exhibit 161, which is your deposition in the case against the National Enquirer, and that's the only other document that you have found responsive to our subpoena. Is that correct?
You talked about that before. Right? You talked about that earlier today, that she would put the two keys on a key chain in a planter in front on her condominium when you and she would go off running when she lived at Bundy. Right?
Oh, no, no. They had an argument. They had an argument about-at the time they had an argument about the kids wanting to play inside, and Michelle doesn't like the kids inside because the house will get dirty, you know, and they had a heated conversation, and then what Nicole did was slap Michelle, and Michelle fell on the floor.
She called me that day and she said, "Don't tell anybody about this, but," you know, "I just couldn't stand Michelle, and Michelle's a crazy woman, and I just slapped her. I couldn't stand the way she talked to me." And that was it. And then Michelle left-
Right. See, one of the reasons why Nicole told me she didn't want to move there unless-unless Michelle lives there , because Michelle and Nicole couldn't get along well.
Well, OJ. thought that Nicole was wrong in doing that, because at the time he told me that she doesn't have -"Nicole doesn't have the right to slap Michelle because," he said, you know, "I'm paying this woman, not Nicole. This is my housekeeper, not Nicole's.. So pretty much that's what-
[Name Deleted] is the bartender of one of the clubs that was very attracted to Nicole, and that's pretty much, you know-as Nicole calls-Nicole called [Name Deleted] the freeloader.
And I had asked you earlier whether Marcus Allen was the only breach of Nicole's understanding with OJ. about being monogamous during the reconciliation period, and you said yes. Then later on you told me about another person with whom she had sex; namely, [Name Deleted].
As I understand the reference in the book, there was a person that Nicole didn't even know and just went into this guy's apartment and had oral sex with somebody.
Was it clear in your mind, as of the time of this Mike Davis incident together with the Marcus Allen situation, that Nicole really wasn't going to be getting back together with Mr. Simpson on a permanent basis?
I am going to be asking you some questions from the statement that you have made to Michael Viner and the people from the National Enquirer that was recorded on tape.
"...Nicole had a lot of friends. She thought she had a lot of friends. When she moved out all of them disappeared, they all went to OJ." You are talking about the time when Nicole got divorced from OJ. Correct?
That didn't stop talking? Well, like Linda Schulman, she was very friendly with Linda Schulman, and she was hurt by the breakup of that relationship, and, you know, a few people. I mean, I don't know the other friends.
At page 6 you state that when Nicole was-after she and OJ. separated and were divorced:
"...I know OJ. wanted to know more about Nicole, whatever Nicole was doing with me because he knew I was out...with her" That's true, that OJ. would waft to find out from you what Nicole was doing. Right?
Okay. You say on page 7 that when Nicole, again, got divorced:
"...nobody supported her, even her family. The family didn't talk to her, nobody was there for her, and she felt really bad about it." Is that what she told you?
"I think part of the reason why OJ. was so upset with Nicole was OJ called Nicole ...- Nicole called _ OJ. and said, 'How dare you buy my...friends? How come you're buying my friends?' -
"The reason why she said that was because...OJ. wrote a check to...Christian for five thousand and something."
Well, he told me that the 5,000 was- they were doing a business, and Faye also told me this, that they were doing a business venture about some pills or whatever, vitamins or whatever. I don't remember. Or jet lag pill, something like that, and that was the $5,000.
Yes, because he said, you know, "Why does she think I'm buying her friends? I'm not buying her friends. Faye was the one who invited herself to go to that sports spectacular."
And you say at page 19 on the same subject, "And so she," referring to Nicole, "called OJ. and said to OJ., 'How dare you buy-you buy everything. You took my friends away, took my family,'" blank, "important in her life," I guess meaning everything important in her life.
What they talked about is - when I said they talked, is they talked because they were gonna have pictures taken, but other than that, I don't know what they talked about, so...
And you say: "...that was the only one that I know, 'cause she really never talked about it, she felt embarrassed, she felt that nobody should know about these things." Is that what Nicole told you?
"See, what happened is Nicole is so afraid of OJ.'s voice. OJ. when...he's upset, I mean, he is really -he's got a very bad temper. And, in fact, Nicole said to OJ., 'If you really went this marriage to work out you're gonna have to go to therapy to control your anger.' And OJ. said, 'Yeah, I'm going to. I'm working on it, I'm working on it."'
Concerning the reason for the beating on New Year's Eve 1989, you mentioned on page 27 of this transcript that the reason why that happened was because of a "pair of earrings."
She sew those pair of earrings and she thought it was hers, and then when she asked OJ. or something like that, she found out it wasn't really hers, but it was for another woman.
Okay. Page 28. You were talking here about OJ. Simpson's statement in his suicide letter that he was a battered spouse, and you were asked about that, and you said:
"Because Nicole didn't know what to do. First, she'd want to go back to the rely on --that she wanted to go back to the relationship. Then she would say...I mean, like they went to -we went to Super Bowl. She said, 'Oh, I have to be nice now to OJ. or else, you know, we won't go. I mean, you know, for you I'll be nice because we're all going to the Super Bowl.' Things like that." Is that what Nicole told you?
Well, on our run we kid around. I mean, she said, "I'd better be nice to him," you know, because she'd never been to a Super Bowl. Yeah, she mentioned that. It's all there.
Talking about Nicole's not willing to make a commitment to OJ. Simpson, on page 30, talking about Nicole going through a phase, and Nicole says, "You know, Cora, well, I'm just going through a phase in my life." And now you continue: "And I remember OJ. used to say, 'Oh, Nicole, you're going '- 'you're gonna go through this, I wonder-'he says, 'I don't know if I can go through when you turn 40, you know: ... He'd kid around. He says, 'You're only 35, and look what happened, you don't even wanna be with me 'cause I'm old:"
Okay. Now, later on on the same page, page 30, you say:
"I felt like he," referring to OJ. Simpson, "was abused too is because she kind of destroyed him to a point where like she really is saying, 'How dare you. You're too old, you know, I don't wanna be with you anymore. You know, you're no fun to be with:"
And then you quote OJ. as saying: "Hey, listen, I'm 47-okay, my knees start cracking, okay, but I've worked hard, I used to (blank) you know, when I was 29 I was...all tight."
And you state, beginning at line 13: "...well, what happened was...I confirmed to OJ. that I knew it. And 'cause-and OJ. didn't like the fact that, uh, people knew about the affair because OJ. thought that it was just him and Nicole who knew about the affair. It turned out we knew.
"And I said, "Well, don't worry about that, you know, I won't say anything: "Nicole confronted me on that one and I didn't like it the way she confronted me. And I said, 'Listen (blank) "But that was it. It wasn't, you know, a major fight
"And Nicole is tough. I mean, she can scream. Well, she has also a bad temper."
Ron Fischman, because OJ. spoke to Ron about their reconcilliation, and when OJ. mentioned about Marcus Allen, Ron did not confirm or deny. And what happened was Nicole got upset that Ron knew about the Marcus Allen, and so Nicole confronted me. She says, "Why"-you know, "Why did you tell Ron," or, "Why did Ron tell Marcus Allen"-
But I am trying to find out what OJ. Simpson said to you about this. Okay? When you spoke to him about this, did he tell you that he was upset that other people knew?
At page 36 you're talking about the early years of Mr. Simpson's relationship with Nicole, and you said in the interview with Mr. Viner, "And I remember OJ. used to say, 'I remember when Nicole was 17, I molded her.'" That's what OJ. Simpson told you. Right?
Ron and I used to kid around about how-you know, Ron used to kid around with me. He says, "I molded you," so I must have used the word molded" with that, yeah, but Nicole was 17 when-
Yeah, she screamed at me in that. She got mad at me and-yeah, that's true. "And I actually blame OJ. for this. I spoke to OJ. at some point and said, 'You know, it's actually your fault, you molded this woman (blank) you know. You exposed her to this lifestyle."'
No, I don't. Right in here you told Mr. Viner that OJ. Simpson said, "I remember when Nicole was 17, I molded her," and you're now denying that OJ. Simpson said that?
I already told you that word "molded" came from Ron, and I always talk about how he molded me because I met Ron when I was young, so-but OJ. never told me about that. Yes, OJ. told me that he met Nicole when he was 17, how she looked so pretty and she was 17 and didn't know anything. Yes, so I must have used the word "molded" from that, but OJ. didn't tell me that.
Probably said that because I was mad. I don't know. But I never used the word "molded," that he molded -I used the word "molded," but OJ. did not say that, "I molded."
The bloodstain was on Ashford side, not on Rockingham side. Why were no blood stains on the carpet going to his bedroom if he came with bloody socks, so...
You tell me that the evidence of his guilt is "enormous." You tell me that it's so enormous that it leads you to suspect that he's being framed, and then you pointed out some of the examples of the evidence that you think was put there to frame him-
They were doing drugs. They were doing cocaine. I mean, not drugs, but Faye was doing cocaine. And they were going out a lot. They were bar-hopping, they were going to different clubs, so at that time I didn't know what they were doing.
Do you-did Mr. Simpson or anyone else ever give you any information to the effect that this glove was planted, this bloody glove? Anyone ever tell you anything about that?
At that time we were trying to commiserate, so at the time I didn't have a friend and-that I could trust, and I thought that we could trust each other, and just trying to figure out what really happened. That's all.
At the time Kato said if I needed a lawyer, that he would help me, and that's pretty much why I met Michael Plotkin. Oh, no. It's because of the National Enquirer. That's true, yeah.
And during these conversations with Kato Kaelin, you also told him that Nicole had ended her relationship with Mr. Simpson sometime in May of 1994, having reached that decision while in Cabo San Lucas. Correct?
Okay. And you told Kato Kaelin that Nicole had-that you had learned that Nicole had planned to have Goldman come over that evening that she was murdered.
Okay. What I said, and I would like to really-I was crying, okay. I went to him. He was sitting with his mother. I was crying, pounding, pounding his chest, and I was crying. I said, "What happened? What happened here? Who did this to my friend? And all that she wanted to do was take care of Sydney and Justin."
And OJ. said, "I just loved her so much. I just loved her so much," and then that was it. That was the end of the conversation.
See, you asked me also about that yesterday, the " too much. n So as I said, you know, if "too" and "so" mean the same, so-so be it, but I said, "I loved her so much. I loved her so much."
Did OJ. Simpson ever tell you that he was thinking about surprising Nicole for her birthday in May of 1994 by renting a yacht and taking Nicole and her friends out on the yacht?
Okay. Did she tell you about a conversation that she had with Mr. Simpson on June 3 or June 2 when they had a vicious argument, and he-and she hung up on him?
Okay. This is where Nicole is describing that OJ. had come over to pick up the kids, came too late, and they slept over at the house, and then she's writing down the things that OJ. had said to her at that time. Do you see that?
They were fighting over-about their friends, you know. Nicole was upset that Faye was invited to the sports spectacular, and I remember Nicole calling me and said, you know, "I can't believe OJ.'s buying my friends," and that's pretty much why they were both fighting.
Because Nicole called OJ., screaming at him, saying, you know, "Why are you taking all my friends away from me? You think you can take my friends again."
And OJ. said, you know, "I wasn't- "I wasn't"-OJ. was denying that. He says, you know, "It was Faye who called me, who wanted to be invited to the sports spectacular," and then- and that's pretty much the conversation.
Well, we talked about that during our run. You know, we kid around. I said, "If anything should happen to us, you know, we'll take care of each other's kids."
On May 22 she says, "we officially split up," and then later on at the end of that entry she says, "He's been gone the last 4 weekends." Do you recall her telling you that?
All I know is at the time when she talked to me about their split-up, I know she said to me,
"We're gonna start talking about every other weekend." You know, "When kids" "when he's around, he should be with the kids. I don't want him to get away with this, he can just take time off and not be with the kids." Yeah, I remember that.
Okay. And on May 28 she says that OJ. went away for Saturday and Sunday but took the kids Friday and Monday. This is Memorial Day weekend. Do you recall that?
"Blow up with Cora in car." Oh, I remember that. We were- when I was gonna pick up the kids -I went to pick up the kids in the morning, because I asked Nicole- I think that was when Nicole had pneumonia or something like that. I don't remember. But I went to pick up their kids to go to school, to [Name Deleted], and so Nicole called me in my car and said that OJ. wants to take the kids to school.
"But"-I said, "But that's okay. I already have them in the car.."
And so as I was going through Bundy by the corner of Gretna Green, OJ. was behind me, and he toot the horn and he said, "Let me take the kids to school."
And so I said, "Well, I have the kids with me."
He says, "No. I'll take the kids to school."
I said, "Okay, fine." So the kids got out and they went with their dad.
She said that OJ.'s mad at me. I said, "Why?" At that time I think OJ. thought that I was the bad influence to Nicole's life because of my affair with [Name Deleted].
He suspected that she was having an affair with [Name Deleted], and he asked me, he says, 'Are they having an affair?' I said, 'No. They're just friends.' And he says, 'Well, someone's eating the caviar and champagne every time I leave.'
OJ's suspicion-laced remark about Alessandro reveals his jealousy and surveillance of Nicole's life even after the separation.
Cora Fischman
Nicole told me, 'Don't ever, whatever happens, don't ever tell OJ. that I had an affair before I left Rockingham,' and I—I made a promise to her.
Establishes that Cora actively concealed Nicole's affair from OJ at Nicole's explicit request, and that she kept that secret even when OJ directly asked her.
Cora Fischman
She apparently wanted to know if I was there, and I told [Name Deleted], 'Tell her I'm not here, because I don't want to go home.' And so Nicole apparently said, 'Tell her to go home because her kids are looking for her and Ron is angry. Ron's been calling.'
Describes the 2 a.m. phone call on June 12 — the last night of Nicole's life — and the ordinary domestic concerns Nicole was expressing just hours before the murders.
Cora Fischman
He says, you know, 'I love that woman.' You know, 'We had such a great marriage. What happened?'
OJ's own words, relayed through Cora, expressing continued emotional attachment to Nicole during their separation — part of Petrocelli's effort to establish obsessive control.
Cora Fischman
She told me to loosen up. She says, you know, 'Cora, you have such a bad marriage. Why don't you just relax, and probably this will help your marriage in the long run.'
Nicole's advice to Cora to pursue an extramarital affair — which later puts Cora at [Name Deleted]'s home on the night of June 11-12, connecting the affair to Nicole's final known conversation with [Name Deleted].
Evidence (4)
Plaintiffs' 160
Piece of paper intended to provide identifying and contact information for Cora's boyfriend [Name Deleted], omitted from the transcript, marked as Plaintiffs' Exhibit 160, and retained by Petrocelli
marked for identification, retained by Petrocelli, omitted from transcript
Informal
Photograph of OJ Simpson that Cora previously gave to Robert Shapiro and Marcia Clark
discussed; Cora could not produce it as it had been handed over to criminal case parties
Informal
Brooke Skulski book notes referenced in prior subpoena
Cora searched for them but could not locate them
Informal
Birthday party photograph of Nicole and Cora, 1993
discussed as one of very few photographs Cora possesses of Nicole
Notable Exchanges (5)
Daniel Petrocelli•Phil Baker•Philip Kramer
Dispute over whether to put [Name Deleted]'s full name and address on the record, with Baker citing press harassment concerns (parallel to how Kim Goldman's friends' information was handled), Kramer citing privacy interests, and Petrocelli insisting on the information for subpoena purposes. Resolved by having Cora write it on a paper exhibit omitted from the transcript and retained by Petrocelli.
strategic
Daniel Petrocelli•Phil Baker
Baker accuses Petrocelli of 'invading this woman's privacy rights in an attempt to harass her' when Petrocelli presses on how Nicole instigated Cora's affair; Petrocelli responds dryly: 'You are getting very good, Mr. Baker.' Baker: 'Thank you.'
heated with dark humor
Daniel Petrocelli•Cora Fischman
Petrocelli confronts Cora with the fact that she failed to mention Nicole's 2 a.m. phone call to [Name Deleted] the day before. Cora deflects by saying Petrocelli hadn't specifically asked. Petrocelli walks through the full sequence — Nicole calling, Cora instructing [Name Deleted] to lie about her whereabouts, and then the one-hour follow-up call the next morning.
revealing
Daniel Petrocelli•Cora Fischman
Petrocelli presses Cora repeatedly on whether Nicole ever discussed physical abuse or the 1989 New Year's Eve beating as a reason for leaving the marriage. Cora denies Nicole ever raised the physical abuse with her, instead attributing the split to womanizing and OJ's absence. Petrocelli's repeated leading attempts are objected to by Baker.
strategic
Cora Fischman•Philip Kramer
After Petrocelli announces he will go to the judge if Cora refuses to answer how Nicole instigated the affair, Kramer pulls Cora aside for an off-record consultation. She then answers.
procedural
Light Moments (3)
Daniel Petrocelli
After Petrocelli notes Cora held a press conference between deposition sessions to deny sleeping with OJ Simpson, he moves on with 'Okay' — treating it as an entirely normal piece of preparation.
Phil Baker
Baker corrects Petrocelli when he says 'Keith' but means '[Name Deleted]': 'MR. BAKER: [Name Deleted].' — Baker stepping in to clean up a naming error.
Phil Baker
When Petrocelli responds sarcastically to Baker's privacy objection — 'You are getting very good, Mr. Baker' — Baker replies 'Thank you.'
Credibility Attacks (2)
⚔ Cora Fischman
omission / prior incomplete testimony
Petrocelli points out that Cora failed to mention Nicole's 2 a.m. phone call to [Name Deleted] during the prior day's session, despite being asked about her contact with Nicole on June 11-12. Cora's defense — 'You didn't ask me' — is noted but Petrocelli treats it as a significant gap.
⚔ Cora Fischman
bias
Petrocelli flags that Cora's concealment of Nicole's affair from OJ, and her own affair with [Name Deleted] (which Nicole was aware of and encouraged), establishes a web of loyalties and secrets that may color her testimony. Petrocelli explicitly names 'bias' when Cora asks why it matters.
Occasionally pushes back on the framing of questions ('No, that's not why')
Appears confused tracking the chronological sequence of Nicole's relationships, saying 'I'm getting confused now'
Willing to volunteer information when she feels the context is being misrepresented (cuts off Petrocelli to correct his characterization of Nicole's motivation)
Consulted privately with her attorney (Philip Kramer) before answering the sensitive question about how Nicole instigated the affair