📂 Wednesday, July 26, 1995 — Day 122
◀ Criminal Trial
📅 Wednesday, July 26, 1995 16 proceedings 1672 lines
Address:
C:\DEPT103\CRIMINAL\1995\JUL\26
TRIAL
▲ Day 122 of 167

Day 122 — Wednesday, July 26, 1995

Defense and Prosecution Clash Over FBI Chemist's EDTA Methodology
Judge Lance A. Ito • Criminal Trial • 16 proceedings • 1672 lines
tense

Day 122 focused on competing examinations of FBI chemist Roger Martz's EDTA testing of blood from the sock and rear gate. Clark emphasized the distinction between detecting and identifying a compound and elicited testimony that EDTA was not positively identified in the evidence stains. Blasier challenged Martz's methodology through destroyed raw data, undocumented procedures, sample-quantity estimates, stability assumptions, and ion-count comparisons. On recross, Clark elicited testimony that oversampling favored detection of any EDTA signal and challenged a defense chart, while Blasier continued disputing detection limits before Martz defended his experience.

  • Defense granted motion to treat FBI Agent Martz as hostile witness
  • Clark established critical distinction between 'detecting' versus 'identifying' EDTA compounds
  • Blasier exposed that Martz destroyed raw mass spectrometry data for key evidence samples
  • Martz admitted conducting an 'informal dilution experiment' 'for dramatic effect' with no documentation
  • Martz could not recall the value of pi, prompting judicial intervention and damaging his credibility as forensic expert
  • Defense used Martz's metal-to-metal ion-count data to argue for an approximately 14-fold difference rather than the thousand-fold difference the prosecution's charts implied
  • Multiple sidebars erupted over exhibit admissibility and chart methodology
  • Martz conceded he never attempted larger blood quantity tests despite suspecting EDTA might be present
Day 122 • 16 proceedings • 1672 lines
Criminal Trial
Department 103
📂 Day 122 — JUL 26, 1995
JUL 26, 1995