FURTHER REDIRECT EXAMINATION
YOU HEARD MR. BAILEY USE THE TERM "A WEAK WOMAN." BECAUSE A WOMAN IS A VICTIM OF BATTERING, DOES THAT MEAN SHE IS WEAK?
NO, NOT AT ALL.
Clean, unambiguous rebuttal to Bailey's 'weak woman' framing — short but effective rehabilitation.
ARE YOU FAMILIAR -- YOU HEARD ABOUT -- SOME QUESTIONS ABOUT A WOMAN RETURNING BACK AND GOING BACK TO THE BATTERER. ARE YOU FAMILIAR -- I SAID A COUPLE. ARE YOU FAMILIAR -- ARE YOU FAMILIAR WITH ANY STUDIES THAT TALK ABOUT THE EFFECT UPON A WOMAN UPON HER ATTACHMENT OR HER BONDING TO A MAN WHEN SHE HAS BEEN SUBJECTED TO UNPREDICTABLE OR INTIMATE VIOLENCE?
I WROTE THREE OF THEM.
In response to being asked if she was familiar with studies on the subject, the witness revealed she herself authored three such studies — a powerful credibility moment undercutting any implication that her views were secondhand or fringe.
WELL, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT HAPPENS WITH BATTERED WOMEN IS THAT IS SOMETHING CALLED TRAUMATIC BONDING WHICH IS A KIND OF PECULIAR PROCESS, BUT BASICALLY IT WORKS LIKE THIS: WE GET ATTACHED TO PEOPLE WHO INTERMITTENTLY TREAT US WELL, BADLY, WELL, BADLY, WHERE THERE IS POSITIVE-NEGATIVE REPEATED BEHAVIOR. ONE OF THE EFFECTS OF TRAUMATIC BONDING IS THAT WITH TIME AWAY FROM THE ABUSER A WOMAN FORGETS THE NEGATIVE STUFF AND REMEMBERS WHAT WAS GOOD ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIP. I HAVE SEEN IT HAPPEN WITHIN A WEEK, BUT IT CAN CERTAINLY TAKE A LONGER TIME PERIOD.
Directly counters the defense implication that Nicole's returns to OJ were evidence the abuse wasn't serious or that she was complicit — reframing it as a documented psychological phenomenon.
I WROTE THREE OF THEM.
WE GET ATTACHED TO PEOPLE WHO INTERMITTENTLY TREAT US WELL, BADLY, WELL, BADLY, WHERE THERE IS POSITIVE-NEGATIVE REPEATED BEHAVIOR. ONE OF THE EFFECTS OF TRAUMATIC BONDING IS THAT WITH TIME AWAY FROM THE ABUSER A WOMAN FORGETS THE NEGATIVE STUFF AND REMEMBERS WHAT WAS GOOD ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIP.
NO, NOT AT ALL.