Petrocelli examines Cora Fischman about her knowledge of the Simpson marriage, Nicole's abuse history, the June 3 IRS confrontation, and events near the end of Nicole's life. During the Exhibit 86 discussion, Cora says she is shocked by the June 3 IRS entry and that she had not seen it before. In the later Exhibit 88 exchange, she recognizes Nicole's handwriting, says she is surprised Nicole did not tell her about the described beatings, and repeatedly denies prior knowledge of specific incidents. Petrocelli also questions her about reports concerning service of Ron Fischman's deposition subpoena, which she does not confirm as continuing, and uses a hypothetical to probe her categorical distrust of Faye Resnick.
I have some extra questions for you. The next document I am going to show you is Exhibit 165, which is the transcript of your interview with Barbara Walters in 1994. Is everything reflected on this transcript attributed to you accurate –
Ron Fischman has told you that even though this case involves a determination of Mr. Simpson's responsibility for the death of Nicole, he does not want to get involved?
So it's fair to say that you have an understanding that this lawsuit – the outcome of this lawsuit could have an effect on his getting custody of the children. Correct?
Well, because Christian came, and there were like four people who could get into the opening night, so I told them that "That's okay, you know, you guys" – "you four go," and then I, you know...
Well, you know, I said, We'll wait till I get my whole divorce settlement. At that time we were thinking of the three of us doing something at one point in that time.
Even when-before when she just got divorced. One time she said she was – she wanted to open a hair salon, and one time she said she'd like to open where Starbucks used to be, she would like to open like a cafe with jazz music there. You know, she was – she's been thinking about that.
When we – you know, during our run, the first – when they were separated in 1992, she said she would love to have more kids, you know, but not with O.J.
Well, based on your observations of the relationship, is it fair to say that when it was good, it was really good, and when it was bad, it was really bad?
No, she never told me that. She only told me the 1989.
Key quote
Reveals how little Nicole confided about the full scope of the abuse, even to her closest friend — a pattern Petrocelli uses to argue Nicole was ashamed, not that the abuse didn't happen.
She had gotten beat up; he had cheated on her consistently; he's threatening to put her in jail. You don't think these are attributes of a bad relationship?
Yeah, is this – is this – are you halfway through your four questions at this point?
Light moment
Philip Kramer (Cora's attorney) interjects mid-examination to ask Petrocelli 'is this — are you halfway through your four questions at this point?' apparently keeping count of a prior limit Petrocelli agreed to.
If Faye were to testify to that, do you have any reason to think she was lying? If Faye were to testify that O.J. Simpson called her on May 2 or May 3 and said, "I'm going to kill Nicole," do you believe that Faye was lying?
ExchangeDaniel Petrocelli · Cora Fischman
Petrocelli presses Cora on whether she would believe Faye Resnick and Christian Reichardt if they both testified under oath that O.J. said 'I'm going to kill Nicole.' Cora refuses to believe Faye at all, then wavers on Christian before concluding he'd be telling the truth — inadvertently conceding the threat may be credible.
I think Faye's mouth, I think everything as a lie.
Key quote
Cora categorically rejects Faye Resnick's credibility when Petrocelli poses a hypothetical in which Faye would testify that O.J. Simpson said he would kill Nicole.
Okay. Well, let's include messing around as a type of sexual activity between two adults. Are you focusing on what I'm saying now? Okay? So using that in the definition of sexual relationship or sexual activity, did Nicole have any sexual activity with [Name Deleted] at Toscana?
After Nicole's death and after you found out Ron Goldman also had been killed, did you ever talk to any of Ron Goldman's friends, such as [Name Deleted] or anyone else, about Ron's death?
You've talked – have you talked to anybody about Ron's – Ron Goldman's activities that evening, why he was going to Bundy, where he might be going afterwards, anything like that?
I talked to-I don't know. To my friends and to – you know, to my friend Cici at that time and to all those people I talked to. You know, we questioned how – why was he there, what was he doing there, you know, yeah.
Ron – yeah, Ron drove the car because they were both drunk at the time, Faye and Nicole were drunk, and Nicole – and Ron didn't want them to drive the car, so he volunteered. He volunteered to drive them home because he was not drunk?
I was driving down Wilshire and I saw O.J.'s car with a woman, and I called Nicole. I said, you know, "I think O.J.'s with Paula." So that was it. That's my –
You mean to tell me Nicole calls you up and says, "Paula called while I was at Rockingham. I answered the phone. Nothing else happened, and now I'm not going to the wedding"?
Now Mr. Kelly asked you earlier today about your conversations with Nicole concerning the IRS letter, and you said that prior to – Withdrawn. You said that the only time – or the first time that you heard about the dispute that she and O.J. Simpson were having about the IRS situation occurred when the letter arrived, but not before. Do you recall that testimony?
Didn't you, because I questioned you about this, and I told you that Nicole – I asked you about Nicole having a very angry exchange with O.J. Simpson at the house on Bundy on June 3 and that Nicole told you about it after it occurred? Do you recall that testimony that you gave?
Now, it's true that Nicole Simpson told you about this very ugly exchange with O.J. Simpson that she had with him on the evening of June 3, as you previously –
She said, "I can't believe this man is trying to put me into jail. I'm the mother of, you know, the kids" – "I'm the mother of his kids, and he wants me to go to jail."
Key quote
Cora recounts what Nicole told her after the June 3rd IRS confrontation, corroborating that Nicole was upset and called Cora the same day it happened.
No. I – just the conversation – I thought you mean the conversation, but not all of this, no. She didn't tell me all of this. She told me that she had a fight with O.J.
Okay. Nicole writes in this diary entry here or whatever this document was intended to be that O.J. told her as follows on June 3:
"You hung [sic] up on me last night. You're gonna pay for this, bitch, you're holding money from the IRS, you're going to jail you f-----g c--t. You think that you can do any freaking thing you want, you've got it coming – I've already talked to my lawyers about this, bitch – and they'll get you for tax evasion bitch I'll see to it. You're not gonna have a f-----g dime left bitch."
Okay? Now, do you know of any reason why Nicole would ever make up such a thing'
Key quote
Petrocelli reads O.J. Simpson's words as written in Nicole's own hand in Exhibit 86, placing extreme verbal abuse and financial threats just nine days before Nicole's murder.
Cora's response to Petrocelli's question about whether Exhibit 86's June 3 IRS entry shocked her; she then said she had never seen the document before.
So when Nicole wrote here about [Name Deleted] that she was Sydney's girlfriend in the same paragraph about the rest of this material, and that was true also, that [Name Deleted] is a person who is a friend of Sydney. Correct?
Did she tell you about an incident in 1988 when a gay man in Hawaii kissed Justin, and O.J. threw her against the wall in her hotel and on the floor and put bruises on her arms and back? Did she tell you about that event?
And she writes here that in 1978 O.J. beat her up for the first time after Louis and Nunie Marx's anniversary party. Do you know who Louis Marx is? Ever hear that name?
Okay. "Started on the street corner of New York City [sic] 5th Avenue at about 9:00 o'clock. Threw me on the floor hit me kicked me. We went to Sherry Netherland Hotel where he continued to beat me for hours as I kept crawling for the door. Called my mother a whore." She tell you any of that?
Did Nicole ever tell you about an incident where O.J. Simpson, and I am reading from her notes here, "smashed my car (white Mercedes) with baseball bat after visiting [Name Deleted]"?
"He greeted me at the gate – I was too afraid to get out of the car. He did it because I was late, about 7 to [sic] 8 p.m. Westec Security was notified and came. Also the West LAPD came." Do you know anything about that?
The next item on Exhibit 88, from which I'm reading, says:
"Michael Millitello's wedding at Ritz Carlton. O.J. lost his temper at the beach house – hit me, threw me up against the walls. Threw my camera, it broke the paneling – the moldings off the doors to the master bedroom and garage door." Did she ever tell you about that incident?
– mean anything to you? Nicole wrote to her lawyer, Bruce Clemens, in sending these materials over to him:
"The [sic] dates are almost impossible for me to remember. These are the most memorable times – there were plenty of small times where he'd just pushed me or grabbed me hard enough to bruise my arms but they happened so often that I can't remember specifics – Nicole." Did you ever see O.J. Simpson push Nicole or grab her?
Of course, you never saw – Withdrawn. Did you learn of any dispute or argument between Ron Fischman and Nicole about your going out with [Name Deleted]?
– correct? Did you tell O.J. Simpson that when the prosecutors interviewed you in this case, they tried to slant your testimony or make you lie? Did you tell that to O.J. Simpson that the prosecutors –
They didn't make me lie, but they trying to accuse me of saying, "How could you be Nicole's friend if you don't know anything about the abuse?" I said, "But, you know, I never saw it."
Well, no, I didn't – what happened was, I had Gigi – said, "If he has time, could you please sign these." These were not, you know – these were from a friend of mine.
Now, before the tape change I was asking you about an incident where you had requested O.J. Simpson to sign footballs, and you learned that he would not do so because he was upset with you. Could you relate that incident to us and tell us when it occurred?
I just found out later on when Nicole told me that O.J. was upset with me, but I thought he was just busy because he was out of town, and I had left that – you know, I told Gigi to have him sign those.
And you feel – and you got the sense that O.J. Simpson was blaming you in part for the problems he was having in his relationship with Nicole. Correct?
By the way, that incident that Mr. Kelly asked you about this morning concerning Tryst, when you left the restaurant, was there anyone else there in your party?
Do you remember an incident at Los Brisas or Las Brisas where you were with Faye Resnick, Nicole, Cici and Ron Fischman and O.J. Simpson and Christian Reichardt in which the Simpsons started going on a tirade against smoking? Do you remember that?
He wouldn't buy her – based on what you observed and knew of Mr. Simpson's position about Nicole's smoking, you don't think he would buy her a cigarette lighter, do you?
I think Faye's mouth, I think everything as a lie.
Cora categorically rejects Faye Resnick's credibility when Petrocelli poses a hypothetical in which Faye would testify that O.J. Simpson said he would kill Nicole.
Cora Fischman
She said, 'I can't believe this man is trying to put me into jail. I'm the mother of, you know, the kids — I'm the mother of his kids, and he wants me to go to jail.'
Cora recounts what Nicole told her after the June 3rd IRS confrontation, corroborating that Nicole was upset and called Cora the same day it happened.
Daniel Petrocelli
You hung [sic] up on me last night. You're gonna pay for this, bitch, you're holding money from the IRS, you're going to jail you f-----g c--t... I'll see to it. You're not gonna have a f-----g dime left bitch.
Petrocelli reads O.J. Simpson's words as written in Nicole's own hand in Exhibit 86, placing extreme verbal abuse and financial threats just nine days before Nicole's murder.
Cora Fischman
I'm shocked now because of what I —
Cora's response to Petrocelli's question about whether Exhibit 86's June 3 IRS entry shocked her; she then said she had never seen the document before.
Cora Fischman
No, she never told me that. She only told me the 1989.
Reveals how little Nicole confided about the full scope of the abuse, even to her closest friend — a pattern Petrocelli uses to argue Nicole was ashamed, not that the abuse didn't happen.
Evidence (3)
Exhibit 86
Nicole Brown Simpson's handwritten diary/notes including the June 3, 1994 entry documenting O.J. Simpson's threatening, profanity-laced phone call about the IRS situation
Introduced and read aloud to witness
Exhibit 88
Nicole Brown Simpson's handwritten letter to her divorce lawyer Bruce Clemens cataloguing specific beatings by O.J. Simpson across years of the marriage, including incidents in 1978 (Sherry Netherland Hotel, NYC), 1988 (Hawaii), the Mercedes smashing with a baseball bat, and Michael Millitello's wedding
Introduced and read aloud to witness
Informal
Star magazine article referenced by Petrocelli while asking about Nicole's diamond earrings; Petrocelli's question asserted that Cora had been paid to provide information, but her answer addressed only the earrings and did not confirm payment
Referenced during questioning about earrings
Notable Exchanges (4)
Daniel Petrocelli•Cora Fischman
Petrocelli reads from Exhibit 88 materials describing alleged beatings across the marriage, including incidents at the Sherry Netherland Hotel, in Hawaii, involving the smashed Mercedes, and at Michael Millitello's wedding. Cora repeatedly says Nicole had not told her about the incidents and says she is surprised Nicole did not tell her.
devastating
Daniel Petrocelli•Cora Fischman
Petrocelli presses Cora on whether she would believe Faye Resnick and Christian Reichardt if they both testified under oath that O.J. said 'I'm going to kill Nicole.' Cora refuses to believe Faye at all, then wavers on Christian before concluding he'd be telling the truth — inadvertently conceding the threat may be credible.
strategic
Daniel Petrocelli•Cora Fischman
Extended back-and-forth over whether Cora's prior testimony about the June 3 IRS incident was consistent. Cora insists she only knew Nicole was upset about the IRS, not the specific language, while Petrocelli pushes her to acknowledge she knew about the fight earlier than she implied.
heated
Daniel Petrocelli•Cora Fischman
Petrocelli presses Cora to agree that the civil lawsuit affected when O.J. would obtain custody of the children. Cora repeatedly rejects that inference, explaining that she understood the timing in terms of the school year and other matters; she separately confirms that it is important to her for the children to be with their father.
strategic
Light Moments (2)
Cora Fischman
When asked if she'd ever been to McDonald's with O.J. Simpson, Cora hesitates and corrects herself before ultimately answering no.
Philip Kramer
Philip Kramer (Cora's attorney) interjects mid-examination to ask Petrocelli 'is this — are you halfway through your four questions at this point?' apparently keeping count of a prior limit Petrocelli agreed to.
Credibility Attacks (3)
⚔ Faye Resnick
Witness opinion / character attack
In response to Petrocelli's hypothetical about proposed testimony by Faye Resnick, Cora says she would not believe Faye and regards everything Faye says as a lie. When Petrocelli extends the hypothetical to Christian Reichardt, Cora ultimately agrees Christian might be telling the truth, qualifying her initial response.
⚔ Cora Fischman
Prior inconsistent statement
Petrocelli confronts Cora with testimony she gave a day or two earlier about when she first learned of the June 3 IRS fight, arguing she is now mischaracterizing what she said. Cora insists she only knew about the general argument, not the specific language.
⚔ Cora Fischman
Bias / motive to protect
Petrocelli asks directly whether Cora is reluctant to say things that might hurt O.J. Simpson, and whether her concern for his children having their father in their lives is shaping her testimony. Cora denies it, but the exchange seeds doubt about her objectivity.
Witness Demeanor
Witness gives halting or fragmented answers and repeatedly expresses uncertainty.
Witness asks 'You said four questions' mid-examination, tracking the stated question limit.
Witness shakes her head in response to a question about Nicole working out at The Gym.
Witness frequently says 'I don't know' and corrects or qualifies her answers.
Witness reports that she was crying during a telephone call with Ron Fischman the night before the deposition.