Redirect examination of Cora Fischman by John Kelly
Witness:Cora Fischman Examiner:John Kelly Called by: Plaintiff • Date: Wednesday, March 20, 1996 •
Lines: 408
John Kelly, representing Nicole's estate, examines Cora Fischman on a mid-May 1994 school incident where OJ intercepted her while she was driving his children, Nicole's threatening phone calls in 1992, and Fischman's National Enquirer lawsuit involving a photo of Nicole and OJ. The examination's sharpest moment comes when Kelly pins Fischman down: the only person Nicole ever said had threatened to kill her was OJ Simpson. The session also covers Fischman's housekeeper arrangements, her $13,000 payment for a Star Magazine article, and her dwindling contact with people in Nicole's circle after the murders.
Good evening, Miss Fischman. My name is John Kelly, and I represent Nicole's estate. I am going to ask you...Miss Fischman, I think you indicated that in a conversation with Mr. Simpson, that he told you that you were Nicole's only true friend. Is that correct? Or her best friend?
No, no. I think what happened was I was the one that- I saw Nicole every day, so we assumed that-you know, we were best friends. We saw each other every day.
See, at the time Nicole told me that he was mad at me because he thought that I was the one messing up the- you know, because of my affair. Yeah Nicole told me that OJ. was mad at me.
Okay. The only person you know that there was enormous amount of evidence against and who had said they were going to kill Nicole was Mr. Simpson. Isn't that true also?
To me I was just-I guess to me I was just mad at all these people trying to make money off my, you know, my friend. Like, here's this lady I helped, and stole a picture.
Key quote
Fischman's stated motivation for the National Enquirer lawsuit — somewhat undermined by the revelation she received $13,000 for the same photo in Star Magazine
Last time I spoke to Faye was that -on Highwood when we were-I was driving, and she was driving her Range Rover, and that was it. That was my-the last time I saw her and I talked to her.
Last time I talked to Judy Brown was I think around December of 1994 when we were trying to figure out what to do with the sleep over, when the kids were going to sleep over. Sydney wanted Leslie to go there, but that was it.
THEVIDEOGRAPHER: This concludes the deposition of Cora A. Fischman, Volume II. The number of videotapes used was three. We are going off the record, and the time is approximately 5:19.
Last time I spoke to Faye was that-on Highwood when we were-I was driving, and she was driving her Range Rover, and that was it. That was my-the last time I saw her and I talked to her.
Last time I talked to Judy Brown was I think around December of 1994 when we were trying to figure out what to do with the sleep over, when the kids were going to sleep over. Sydney wanted Leslie to go there, but that was it.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: This concludes the deposition of Cora A. Fischman,Volume II. The number of videotapes used was three. We are going off the record, and the time is approximately 5:19.
The only person that Nicole ever told you had said that they were going to kill her was Mr. Simpson, was it not? Yes. Right.
Kelly's most damaging exchange — Fischman confirms OJ was the only person Nicole identified as having threatened to kill her
Cora Fischman
He says, 'I want my kids.' ... Nicole told me that OJ. was mad at me.
Establishes OJ's possessive, angry demeanor during the school incident — relevant to pattern of controlling behavior
Cora Fischman
To me I was just mad at all these people trying to make money off my, you know, my friend. Like, here's this lady I helped, and stole a picture.
Fischman's stated motivation for the National Enquirer lawsuit — somewhat undermined by the revelation she received $13,000 for the same photo in Star Magazine
Cora Fischman
Last time I spoke to her was I think after the suicide attempt, you know, my suicide, when I got back from the hospital.
Casual, unremarked disclosure of her own suicide attempt — illustrates the psychological toll on people in Nicole's orbit
Evidence (1)
Informal
Photograph of Nicole and OJ Simpson, taken from Fischman's house by a named individual, published in Star Magazine and the National Enquirer
discussed — Fischman confirms she showed the photo to book publishers and received $13,000 from Star Magazine for the article in which it appeared
Notable Exchanges (3)
John Kelly•Cora Fischman
Kelly walks Fischman through the process of eliminating Judy and Faye as sources of kill threats, landing on OJ as the only person Nicole ever identified as having threatened her life — and Fischman confirms it without resistance
devastating
John Kelly•Cora Fischman
Kelly probes the Star Magazine payment ($13,750 vs. $13,000) and Fischman's plan to use the Nicole/OJ photo in a potential book, creating tension with her stated indignation about people profiting from Nicole's death
strategic
John Kelly•Cora Fischman
Kelly tries to establish whether OJ took Sydney and Justin back to Bundy before dropping them at school — Fischman cannot confirm or deny, saying 'I don't know' multiple times
inconclusive
Light Moments (2)
Philip Kramer
Philip Kramer interrupts mid-deposition to ask what time proceedings start tomorrow, prompting brief cross-talk among counsel before the examination resumes
Cora Fischman
Fischman, apparently confused about whether they are finished for the day, asks 'Are we done? Okay' and then checks the clock: '5:30? Okay.' Kelly corrects her: '5:25.'
Credibility Attacks (2)
⚔ Cora Fischman
bias / financial interest
Kelly establishes that Fischman received $13,000 from Star Magazine for an article using the Nicole/OJ photo, and that she showed the photo to potential book publishers — undermining her stated outrage at people profiting from Nicole's death
⚔ Cora Fischman
prior inconsistent statement / implausibility
Kelly presses whether OJ said he would kill Nicole in the same breath that she claimed he only mentioned kill as a figure of speech — Fischman ultimately confirms OJ was the one exception who used it as a real threat
Witness Demeanor
Frequently asks questions back at examiner before answering ('Why?' 'What?' 'If I actually know?')
Often uncertain and hedging ('I don't know,' 'I think so,' 'I'm not sure')
Appears more forthcoming and direct when discussing OJ's anger and the kill-threat confirmation
Deflects or pleads ignorance on legally sensitive topics (copyright purpose, book plans)