📄 Reporter identification — Tuesday, September 5, 1995
Address:
C:\DEPT103\CRIMINAL\1995\SEP\5\REPORTER-IDENTIFICATION.DOC
TRIAL
▲ Day 147 of 167

Reporter identification

Date: Tuesday, September 5, 1995 • Utterances: 68
A pre-session administrative hearing covering multiple discovery matters from an ongoing 1054.7 proceeding: the court ordered disclosure of Dr. De Forest's sock-examination photos and notes, a photograph of Simpson wearing a glove, and received prosecution offers of proof for rebuttal witnesses Bodziak and Popovich. Kathleen Bell's personal attorney appeared to request privacy protections ahead of her testimony, and a dispute arose over whether the prosecution could interview upcoming witness Natalie Singer. The session ended with an unidentified woman being escorted from the courtroom after shouting a message she claimed was from God.
1 (Appearances as heretofore noted; also appearing, Taylor J. Daigneault, Esquire, for Kathleen Bell; Matthew Schwartz, Esquire, and Ron Regwan, Esquire, for Laura Hart McKinny.)
2 (Janet M. Moxham, CSR no. 4855, official reporter.)
3 (Christine M. Olson, CSR no. 2378, official reporter.)
4 (Pages 43806 through 43813, volume 216B, transcribed and sealed under separate cover.)
5 (The following proceedings were held in open court, out of the presence of the jury:)
6 THE COURT:

All right. Back on the record in the Simpson matter. The Defendant is again present before the court with his counsel, Mr. Shapiro, Mr. Cochran, Mr. Bailey and Mr. Blasier. The People are represented by Mr. Hodgman, Mr. Yochelson, Mr. Darden and Miss Lewis. The jury is not present. Counsel, the record should reflect that this morning, as a continuation of a hearing that began last week, the court conducted a 1054.7 hearing with the Prosecution and I will advise Defense counsel of the following orders by the Court: As to Dr. De Forest, the court will order the disclosure of the package of photographs and notes by Dr. De Forest as they relate to the sock examinations conducted by Dr. De Forest. My understanding, Mr. Hodgman, is the photographs that you intend to turn over are the photograph that you turned over to the court for examination; is that correct?

7 MR. HODGMAN:

Yes. Good morning, your Honor, and that is correct.

8 THE COURT:

All right. I will give this to Mrs. Robertson for turning over to the Defense. I'm going to direct you to turn over any written materials from Dr. De Forest by the close of business today. My recollection is you indicated that those had to be numbered for discovery purposes?

9 MR. HODGMAN:

Yes, your Honor. And for purposes of the record, I have turned over to Mr. Neufeld this morning an unnumbered set of notes. We will number them per our formal discovery procedures and provide a second copy later in the day.

10 THE COURT:

All right. Counsel, the--where is Mr. Douglas? Mr. Douglas?

11 MR. DOUGLAS:

Your Honor.

12 THE COURT:

Mr. Hodgman advised the court that Dr. De Forest would be testifying only to the sock or very limited avenues of inquiry. I had a concern, given the number of notes that Dr. De Forest had, that there might be some Brady materials, so Mr. Hodgman has given to me a complete set of Dr. De Forest's notes, plus the notes that he has turned over to you, so that I can compare both, and I will have to examine those over the noon hour, or perhaps this evening, to see if there is any Brady material or anything else that I think should be disclosed.

13 MR. DOUGLAS:

Thank you, your Honor.

14 THE COURT:

So you might want to remind me of that later this week.

15 MR. HODGMAN:

Your Honor, point of correction if I may. Mr. De Forest will be testifying with regard to the socks, but it is also possible he will be covering some other limited areas as well, so for the edification of the court and counsel, there may be some other areas involved.

16 THE COURT:

All right. Second item was a photograph of Mr. Simpson wearing a glove and the court noted that it would allow the Prosecution to withhold discovery of this item until the investigation had been completed. I understand that that has been accomplished; is that correct?

17 MR. YOCHELSON:

Yes, your Honor. In essence, yes.

18 THE COURT:

The photograph and notes you turned over to the court, this is the copy you intend on turning over to the Defense, correct?

19 MR. YOCHELSON:

Yes, your Honor.

20 THE COURT:

I will likewise direct Mrs. Robertson to give this to the Defense. All right. As to Mr. Bodziak, Mr. Hodgman?

21 MR. HODGMAN:

Yes, your Honor. We have indicated to the court, as well as counsel, that we do intend to call Mr. Bodziak in our rebuttal case. We have no report from Mr. Bodziak, nor do we have any reports as of yet. If and when we receive those we will turn over those over to the Defense in prompt fashion.

22 THE COURT:

This is a rebuttal case. What is your offer of proof as to Mr. Bodziak?

23 MR. HODGMAN:

Mr. Bodziak will be testifying with regard to his impression of some impressions and the--at the Bundy crime scene on the walkway, and in addition to--in a limited fashion to some general testimony about what one can perceive or can't perceive with regard--in crime scene photographs. And then based upon some information contained in his book, which I believe the Defense has, various limitations of what one should testify to based upon what can be deprived from photographs. So this is still being refined, your Honor. As it becomes more refined we will--and to the extent that we get notes, we will provide that to the Defense.

24 THE COURT:

All right. As to Mr. Popovich, do you intend or have you made your decision as to whether or not you are going to call Mr. Popovich?

25 MR. HODGMAN:

We intend to call Mr. Popovich. We have turned over notes that we have received from Mr. Popovich. At the moment the Defense has what we have and no more. To the extent that we get anything in addition from Mr. Popovich, we will turn that over as well.

26 THE COURT:

All right. What is your offer of proof since it is likewise going to be a rebuttal witness? What is your offer of proof as to Mr. Popovich?

27 MR. HODGMAN:

As contained in the notes that we have turned over to the Defense, Mr. Popovich's tours, if you will, of the Department of Justice crime lab, as well as the LAPD crime lab and observations of both those locations and some related testimony regarding contamination.

28 THE COURT:

All right. And lastly, in response to Mr. Neufeld's question, you were going to advise Defense counsel and the court whether or not at this time you intend on calling an EDTA witness.

29 MR. HODGMAN:

At this time, your Honor, we do not intend to call any EDTA witnesses.

KEY QUOTE
30 THE COURT:

All right. Mr. Douglas--where did Mr. Douglas go? All right. Any other comment as to these discovery matters?

31 MR. DOUGLAS:

No, your Honor. Ready to proceed.

32 THE COURT:

All right. All right. Anything else we need to take up before we invite the jurors to rejoin us?

33 MR. DAIGNEAULT:

Your Honor, I wonder if I may be heard briefly on behalf of Miss Bell?

34 THE COURT:

Good morning, counsel. Would you identify yourself for the record.

35 MR. DAIGNEAULT:

My name is Taylor Daigneault. I am the attorney from Miss Bell. As your Honor knows from the declaration that Miss Bell provided at an earlier time there has been an intensive investigation of Miss Bell. I would like to attend this morning and--before the jury came in I would like to ask the court if I could be heard on objections concerning right of privacy and possibly attorney/client privilege. My concern, your Honor, is that the investigation of Miss Bell has been very intense, but as I have seen the things that have unfolded in this courtroom in the past few weeks, I think that her testimony is--is almost beyond question the truthful testimony, and I would like the court to give some quarter to protecting her privacy rights, if the need arises, in terms of the cross-examination or her direct examination.

36 THE COURT:

All right. Counsel, I will allow you to sit inside the bar at the time that Miss Bell is being questioned and you may of course raise any--on her behalf, any attorney/client privilege objections that you might have. Issues of privacy, though, are a different question, and if you wish time to consult with your client and consult with other counsel, I will allow you leave to do so.

37 MR. DAIGNEAULT:

I haven't had an opportunity to talk with any member of the Prosecution team, so I don't know what they are going to inquire into in terms of her personal past. I do know that the telephone records were subpoenaed, the numbers were called, her social friends have been contacted. Several investigators from the District Attorney's office called her hair dresser, or so I have been advised, and I don't know what they have discovered along the way, but I would--if they are going to inquire into her personal life, she has--she has a family law file that is some twenty years old, I believe, or something close to that. I would just like some limitations into this field, especially in light of developments recently. Her testimony I think is--if your Honor would weigh these factors, I think her testimony is not all that remarkable in light of what other evidence has been submitted to the court recently.

38 THE COURT:

All right. Well, the court is apprised of the issue.

39 MR. DAIGNEAULT:

Thank you, your Honor.

40 THE COURT:

All right. Thank you, counsel. If you want, you can take a seat over next to Mr. Regwan over there.

41 MR. DAIGNEAULT:

Yes.

42 THE COURT:

Miss Lewis, good morning.

43 MS. LEWIS:

Good morning, your Honor. A couple of brief matters. First I believe that Natalie Singer is here or available certainly to the Defense, since she has been moved to second on their witness list for this morning. The first request is that we have an opportunity to interview her, which we have not had previously. The short break that was taken Friday Mr. Darden was not able to accomplish that during the short break taken Friday, so we would request that we be permitted to interview her somewhere up in our offices or wherever is convenient.

44 THE COURT:

If she is willing to be interviewed, yes.

45 MR. COCHRAN:

No problem, your Honor.

46 THE COURT:

We will probably take a recess between witnesses, I suspect, given our late start this morning.

47 MS. LEWIS:

That is Natalie Singer. Mr. Bailey was just inquiring. The other thing I wanted to bring to the court's attention is that the Defense has on their current witness list Kathleen Bell, then Natalie Singer, then Andrea Terry. It is my expectation, and these are Mr. Darden's witnesses so I don't mean to--but it is our expectation that we will be bringing a motion after Kathleen Bell testifies renewing in essence the motion I argued a few weeks ago with regard to the additional witnesses being cumulative. Detective Fuhrman was cross-examined with regard to Andrea Terry, and if they choose for tactical reasons to try and wedge in Miss Singer--

48 THE COURT:

Well, that is an issue we need to address once we see Miss Bell.

49 MS. LEWIS:

All right. And I just want to remind the court, the court had ruled that no one else--there would be a possible issue that they be cumulative once Bell and Terry testified.

50 THE COURT:

I wouldn't call it a ruling that there is a possible issue, but yes, the issue is there.

51 MS. LEWIS:

All right.

52 THE COURT:

I think we discussed this ad nauseam Friday.

53 MS. LEWIS:

I heard the discussion. I wasn't present, but I did hear of it.

54 THE COURT:

All right.

55 MS. LEWIS:

The only other thing I wanted to mention, your Honor, is this morning I filed a responsive brief to the Defense motion, renewed motion to suppress based on newly discovered evidence, and I have noted in the Defense line-up they anticipate reaching argument on that at some point today. And of course the court must have an opportunity to read our response before I'm sure we will be able to assess the issues and to rule on the matter, and I just wanted to alert the court that it had been filed and it had been available.

56 THE COURT:

I think that is an optimistic scenario timewise. All right. Mr. Bailey, are you ready to proceed?

57 MR. BAILEY:

I am, your Honor, but first let me point out you are not being given the facts. On Friday I put on the record that Miss Singer had been inquired of as to whether she wished to be interviewed and her response was that they have known about me for six months, I have a lawyer in Nashville, I have one here who went out of town for the weekend, and they are too late. I'm not going to talk to them. Furthermore, why should I be trashed the way Kathleen Bell was? I get a call from Mr. Hodgman last night wanting to interview her. I said, you know what is in the record. I can't speak for her lawyer. She hasn't changed her mind. That was true this morning. So taking a recess to interview her, which they know full well is an imposition on a much beleaguered jury--

58 THE COURT:

All right. We will take that up.

59 MR. DARDEN:

Your Honor, there will be a 402 as relates to Miss Singer. We have no specific details as to what she is going to testify to. We have no offer of proof.

60 THE COURT:

Like I said, we will take this up after we finish Miss Bell. All right. Are you ready?

61 MR. BAILEY:

Yes.

62 THE COURT:

All right. Deputy Magnera, let's have the jury, please.

63 (Brief pause.)
64 (The following proceedings were held in open court, in the presence of the jury:)
65 AN UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN:

Judge Ito, I have a message to you from God. God wants you to play the tapes. This is a message from God.

KEY QUOTE
66 (An unidentified woman is escorted from the courtroom.)
67 (Brief pause.)
68 (The following proceedings were held in open court, in the presence of the jury:)

Temperature

procedural

Key Quotes (4)

Mr. Daigneault
I think that her testimony is--is almost beyond question the truthful testimony, and I would like the court to give some quarter to protecting her privacy rights
Bell's personal attorney vouches for her credibility while seeking judicial protection from invasive cross-examination, signaling the defense expects aggressive impeachment of their own witness
William Hodgman
At this time, your Honor, we do not intend to call any EDTA witnesses.
Prosecution formally abandons the EDTA blood-preservative theory, a significant strategic retreat from their earlier position on the planted-blood issue
F. Lee Bailey
They have known about me for six months, I have a lawyer in Nashville, I have one here who went out of town for the weekend, and they are too late. I'm not going to talk to them. Furthermore, why should I be trashed the way Kathleen Bell was?
Bailey relays Singer's refusal to be interviewed, framing it as witness intimidation and invoking Bell's rough treatment as a deterrent
An Unidentified Woman
Judge Ito, I have a message to you from God. God wants you to play the tapes. This is a message from God.
Courtroom disruption referencing 'the tapes'—almost certainly the McKinny/Fuhrman tapes—underscoring how publicly charged that evidence had become

Evidence (4)

Informal
Dr. De Forest's photographs and notes relating to his sock examinations
Ordered disclosed to defense by close of business; court retaining copy to review for Brady material
Informal
Photograph of O.J. Simpson wearing a glove
Investigation completed; court ordered turned over to defense
Informal
FBI agent Bodziak's analysis of shoe impressions at the Bundy crime scene walkway and limitations of crime scene photography
Offer of proof given; no written report yet; to be provided upon receipt
Informal
Popovich's notes from tours of DOJ and LAPD crime labs regarding contamination
Notes already turned over; prosecution to supplement if additional materials received

Notable Exchanges (3)

F. Lee BaileyChristopher DardenLance A. Ito
Bailey pushed back hard on the prosecution's request to interview Natalie Singer, revealing she had refused through her attorneys. Darden responded that he had no offer of proof for Singer and would need a 402 hearing. The court deferred until after Bell's testimony.
strategic
Mr. DaigneaultLance A. Ito
Bell's personal attorney described an intensive investigation of his client—subpoenaed phone records, interviews with social contacts, and even her hairdresser—and asked the court to limit inquiry into her personal life, including a 20-year-old family law file. The court allowed him to sit inside the bar and raise privilege objections but declined to pre-limit cross-examination.
tense
Cheri LewisLance A. Ito
Lewis flagged a forthcoming motion to exclude Singer and Andrea Terry as cumulative once Bell testifies, referencing a prior ruling. The judge gently corrected her framing ('I wouldn't call it a ruling') and noted they had discussed it 'ad nauseam Friday.'
strategic

Light Moments (3)

An Unidentified Woman
An unidentified woman interrupted proceedings to deliver what she said was a divine message—'God wants you to play the tapes'—before being escorted out of the courtroom.
Lance A. Ito
After assigning Douglas to follow up on the Brady review, the judge said 'you might want to remind me of that later this week'—an unusually candid admission of a crowded docket.
Lance A. Ito
When Lewis noted she hadn't been present for Friday's discussion, the judge replied 'I think we discussed this ad nauseam Friday.'

Witness Demeanor

(An unidentified woman is escorted from the courtroom.)
(Brief pause.)

Objections

None recorded
Proceeding 7490 • 68 utterances
Criminal Trial
Department 103
⚖️ Start
📂 SEP 5, 1995 📄 Reporter identification
SEP 5, 1995 KRT DvH TD