📄 Appearances and scheduling — Thursday, September 14, 1995
Address:
C:\DEPT103\CRIMINAL\1995\SEP\14\APPEARANCES-AND-SCHEDULING.DOC
TRIAL
▲ Day 154 of 167

Appearances and scheduling

Date: Thursday, September 14, 1995 • Utterances: 65
A pre-jury administrative session covering the day's witness schedule (concluding with Miss Ramirez, then Deedrick, Bodziak, and a late-added photographer named Adkins), judicial notice of the moon phase on June 12, 1994, the Prosecution's ongoing effort to obtain the Stockdale answering machine tape, and Barry Scheck's announcement that the FBI would allow Agent Whitehurst to testify voluntarily. The session was largely collegial and procedural, with one genuinely light moment over whether jurors would understand the terms 'waxing' and 'waning.'
1 (Appearances as heretofore noted.)
2 (Janet M. Moxham, CSR no. 4855, official reporter.)
3 (Christine M. Olson, CSR no. 2378, official reporter.)
4 (Pages 45745 through 45785, volume 222A, transcribed and sealed under separate cover.)
5 (The following proceedings were held in open court, out of the presence of the jury:)
6 THE COURT:

All right. Back on the record in the Simpson matter. Mr. Simpson is present with counsel, Mr. Shapiro, Mr. Cochran, Mr. Blasier, Mr. Scheck, Mr. Neufeld, People represented by Miss Clark and Mr. Darden. Good morning, counsel.

7 MS. CLARK:

Good morning, your Honor.

8 THE COURT:

All right. As far as scheduling is concerned today, I understand we're going to conclude with Miss Ramirez and then I understand the Prosecution is going to move on to the presentation of Mr. Deedrick and Mr. Bodziak; is that correct?

9 MS. CLARK:

Yes, with one addition, your Honor. I understand that--I think--we have informed counsel we forgot to put on the list a photographer.

10 THE COURT:

Mr. Adkins?

11 MS. CLARK:

Right.

12 MR. COCHRAN:

Your Honor, with regard to that, it would violate the three-day rule. But since the People have only two other witnesses, we need some time to interview Mr. Adkins. So we'll need some time on that and probably we'll be ready after that. I spoke briefly with Mr. Darden about the scope of this. We can talk to Mr. Adkins. We may be able--I believe that's Mr. Neufeld's witness. We may be able to proceed on that, but we'll need some time.

13 MS. CLARK:

He should be very brief.

14 MR. COCHRAN:

May I have an oral estimate? Do the People expect to finish their case either--depending on my cross-examination, by tomorrow at the latest?

15 MS. CLARK:

Well that's what I think. I mean, cross is unpredictable, but my proposed direct is not that extensive. I think we should finish tomorrow.

16 THE COURT:

My guess is Monday.

17 MS. CLARK:

You may be right, your Honor. I mean, I'm optimistic because there is going to be down time today before we get to the witnesses. Everybody wants to talk to everybody, so that may be true. But, you know, hope springs eternal.

18 MR. COCHRAN:

Is today a 6:00 o'clock day? So see, we may be able to finish.

19 MS. CLARK:

Is there any possibility going past noon tomorrow to finish?

20 THE COURT:

It's possible.

21 MS. CLARK:

Okay. If we can.

22 THE COURT:

Let me check because I don't know what other--I mean, I'm going to be here. So--

23 MS. CLARK:

Right. I know. But it's a juror thing.

24 THE COURT:

Right. Let me see what plans we made. I'll check with Deputy Jex to see what other plans, because we may have made doctors' appointments--

25 MS. CLARK:

Right.

26 MR. COCHRAN:

With that thought in mind, your Honor, we will then proceed to try to line up our--the balance of our witnesses starting Monday. So we'll try not to have too much downtime.

27 THE COURT:

That would be a good idea.

28 MR. COCHRAN:

All right. We'll do that.

29 MS. CLARK:

Your Honor, there's one other thing. Two other things. No. 1, we had made a motion for judicial notice on the phase of the moon on June the 12th, and the court granted that motion. So I'd ask that the court--I don't know if the court has it. I have it with me. If the court would read that to the jury prior to the People conditionally resting on rebuttal. And also, the People have made--

30 THE COURT:

All right. I think what you need to do then is make a formal request in front of the jury that the court take judicial notice of that particular phase of the moon.

31 MS. CLARK:

Yes. And I just wanted to make sure--

32 THE COURT:

Is there any objection? That was a request that was made quite some time ago.

33 MR. COCHRAN:

I missed part of it.

34 MS. CLARK:

Judicial notice of the phase of the moon on June 12th.

35 THE COURT:

Submitted?

36 MR. COCHRAN:

Phase of the moon? What's the word? "Increasing"? There was "Waning," "Waxing," remember that word? There was some question about what you were going to do about "Waning" and "Waxing."

37 THE COURT:

I was going to tell them what the appropriate term is, "Waning" and "Waxing," and I assume, since that is a common term, the jurors will know what that means.

38 MS. CLARK:

Anyway, the proposed sentence is here your Honor; on June 12th, 1994, the moon was a cres--we have as a crescent moon with 12 percent. Why not just say then on June the 12th, 1994, the moon was a waxing crescent moon with 12 percent of the moon surface illuminated? And that will satisfy both sides I think.

39 THE COURT:

Fine.

40 MS. CLARK:

And I'll submit that to the court so you have your script in front of you.

41 THE COURT:

Thank you.

42 MS. CLARK:

You're welcome. Also, the People have--

43 THE COURT:

I'm sorry. Excuse me. Mr. Cochran, is that issue submitted?

44 MR. COCHRAN:

Your Honor, the problem is with that, if you recall--I don't want to spend a lot of time on it--instead of using the word "Waxing," I thought we talked "Increasing" because you see--

45 THE COURT:

No. The terminology for the phase of the moon, increasing and decreasing illumination is "Waxing" and "Waning." Everybody knows that.

46 MR. COCHRAN:

Not everybody, your Honor.

47 THE COURT:

Everybody knows that. Who in this courtroom doesn't know that?

KEY QUOTE
48 MR. COCHRAN:

Yes. We just had our focus moved, Judge. So my point is proven.

KEY QUOTE
49 THE COURT:

All right. Is the matter submitted, Mr. Cochran?

50 MR. COCHRAN:

If you'll take the survey.

51 THE COURT:

Is the matter submitted?

52 MR. COCHRAN:

Submitted, your Honor.

53 THE COURT:

Thank you.

54 MS. CLARK:

Lastly, your Honor, the People have made repeated requests for the Stockdale tape. We've attempted to get it from the--from the answering machine company as directed by the court. We submitted a letter, I think a copy of it came to the court with a declaration from the person told to us by Miss Stockdale who indicated they do not keep copies, they do not any longer have a copy of the tape, which means that under Meredith, we're back at our initial starting point, which is that the Defense has altered evidence to a point that we can no longer obtain it by our own means, and we requested of the Defense by a letter I think sent a couple weeks ago to present that tape to us. We would like now to have that tape produced in court.

55 THE COURT:

Who wants to address that for the Defense?

56 MR. COCHRAN:

I can just address it generally. I think that if I recall correctly--and we'll have to get back to this later perhaps. I think we submitted some declarations to the court under seal regarding this, and I'd like the court to pull those up. I don't have copies of that here.

57 THE COURT:

All right. That was during a 1054.7. We need to revisit that because I need to check my notes.

58 MS. CLARK:

Can we do that today, your Honor?

59 THE COURT:

Maybe during the breaks in-between witnesses I can look that up.

60 MS. CLARK:

Okay. Thank you.

61 THE COURT:

All right.

62 MR. SCHECK:

Just for the record, I have just received a letter dated September 13th to Mr. Cochran from James Michael Maddock, deputy counsel of the office of general counsel of the Federal Bureau Of Investigation. And as I previously informed the court, this letter indicates that the bureau does not object to Special Agent Frederick Whitehurst testifying in this matter.

Therefore, a subpoena for his presence is unnecessary. I think we probably should just mark this letter and make a copy for--so that that's before the court. And also, I should put on the record what I think I've previously informed the court. In this letter, Mr. Maddock indicates that the subpoena that we served for records to the FBI--well, it was a subpoena that we served on Mr. Whitehurst's counsel. It was then forwarded to the FBI--was not jurisdictionally valid in so far as it had to go through the federal district court--we've taken measures to do that, and that he has also--it's not reflected in the letter, but he's also agreed and Mr. Whitehurst--dr. Whitehurst has agreed to an interview with both sides in this case with the court reporter present. And hopefully we can arrange that by Saturday and then further discovery can ensue from that. But for purposes of the record, I thought we should just make this part of the record so it's clear.

63 THE COURT:

All right. Yesterday, the Defense filed and then withdrew that out-of-state subpoena request. And, Mrs. Robertson, did you send that down to the main file?

64 THE CLERK:

No your Honor.

65 THE COURT:

All right. It's up here? Okay. Okay. All right. Let's have the jury, please.

Temperature

light

Key Quotes (5)

Lance A. Ito
Everybody knows that. Who in this courtroom doesn't know that?
Ito's confident assertion that 'waxing' and 'waning' are universally understood — immediately undercut when someone in court lost focus, which Cochran gleefully noted as proof of his point.
Johnnie Cochran
Yes. We just had our focus moved, Judge. So my point is proven.
Rare moment of genuine courtroom levity; Cochran scores a comic point against Ito in real time.
Marcia Clark
the Defense has altered evidence to a point that we can no longer obtain it by our own means
A serious allegation: Clark claims the answering machine company no longer has the Stockdale tape, placing responsibility on the Defense under the Meredith doctrine.
Barry Scheck
this letter indicates that the bureau does not object to Special Agent Frederick Whitehurst testifying in this matter. Therefore, a subpoena for his presence is unnecessary.
Clears a procedural hurdle for what was expected to be significant FBI lab testimony, and flags that both sides would get an interview with Whitehurst before he testified.
Marcia Clark
hope springs eternal
Clark's wry aside on whether they'd actually finish the prosecution's case by Friday — Ito had already quietly predicted Monday.

Evidence (3)

Informal
Stockdale answering machine tape — prosecution alleges Defense altered or withheld it; answering machine company confirms they no longer have a copy
disputed, production demanded
Informal
Judicial notice of moon phase on June 12, 1994 — 'a waxing crescent moon with 12 percent of the moon surface illuminated'
agreed language finalized, to be read to jury
Informal
Letter dated September 13 from FBI Deputy Counsel James Michael Maddock confirming Whitehurst may testify voluntarily
introduced into record by Scheck

Notable Exchanges (3)

Lance A. ItoJohnnie Cochran
Debate over whether to use 'waxing/waning' vs. 'increasing' to describe the moon phase for the jury. Ito insists everyone knows the terms; Cochran disagrees; someone in court drifts off mid-argument, vindicating Cochran.
light
Marcia ClarkLance A. Ito
Clark presses for the Stockdale tape to be produced in court, citing the Meredith doctrine and the answering machine company's declaration that no copy exists. Ito agrees to revisit the sealed declarations during a break.
strategic
Lance A. ItoMarcia ClarkJohnnie Cochran
Scheduling discussion about whether the prosecution's rebuttal case can finish by Friday or will bleed into Monday; Cochran asks if it's a '6 o'clock day,' Clark floats going past noon Saturday.
collegial

Light Moments (2)

Johnnie Cochran
Ito declares 'Everybody knows' what waxing and waning mean, then someone in the courtroom immediately proves they don't by losing focus. Cochran: 'Yes. We just had our focus moved, Judge. So my point is proven.'
Johnnie Cochran
Cochran asks 'Is today a 6:00 o'clock day?' as a way of calculating whether they might finish the prosecution case sooner.

Objections

None recorded
Proceeding 7683 • 65 utterances
Criminal Trial
Department 103
⚖️ Start
📂 SEP 14, 1995 📄 Appearances and scheduling
SEP 14, 1995 KRT DvH TD