📄 Exhibits and scheduling — Friday, September 22, 1995
Address:
C:\DEPT103\CRIMINAL\1995\SEP\22\EXHIBITS-AND-SCHEDULING.DOC
TRIAL
▲ Day 160 of 167

Exhibits and scheduling

Date: Friday, September 22, 1995 • Utterances: 69
The defense formally rests, with O.J. Simpson waiving his right to testify after delivering a brief personal statement to the court over Marcia Clark's strenuous objection. Both sides then process a series of exhibit substitutions, redactions, and withdrawals, and the court discusses extending hours for closing arguments.
1 THE COURT:

All right. I think I'm bound by the ruling of the court of appeal on that issue, so I will decline the request. All right. One last thing that we need to do. Mr. Cochran, I indicated to you previously that I wanted to make certain--my understanding is that the Defense is going to rest today, as is the Prosecution, in front of the jury, and that your client--you have discussed with your client his right to testify as a witness and it is your choice and his agreement that the Defense rests at this time without presenting his testimony?

2 MR. COCHRAN:

Your Honor, may I respond?

3 THE COURT:

Yes.

4 MR. COCHRAN:

Good morning, your Honor.

5 THE COURT:

Good morning.

6 MR. COCHRAN:

In this regard, just two quick things if the court pleases. We do--at the time we rest we will move the court for a motion of acquittal on behalf of Mr. Simpson and submit that, if the court pleases. And Mr. Simpson would like to make a brief statement with regard to the reported--Mr. Simpson would like to make a brief statement regarding the waiver, if the court pleases.

7 THE COURT:

Certainly. This is his knowledge that he has the right to testify?

8 MR. COCHRAN:

Yes. With regard to the last thing, we would at the appropriate time move the balance of our exhibits into evidence whenever you deem that is appropriate. Mr. Douglas has some--some numbers for redacted videos and various things.

9 THE COURT:

All right.

10 MS. CLARK:

Your Honor, the People would object to the Defendant making any statement in court other than a waiver. That is the only appropriate statement that he should be making on the record at this time.

11 THE COURT:

All right. It is not before the jury at this point.

12 MS. CLARK:

Your Honor, you know, we are all aware of the realities of life in this case and the problem with conjugal visits and the problem with telephone calls that are only monitored on one side. And this is a very obvious attempt by the Defense to again get material admitted through those conjugal visits and telephone calls that has not been admitted in court. I urge the court strenuously to exercise control here, take the waiver and do not permit basically allocution, that is, testimony without any cross-examination. It is inappropriate and it is done very deliberately by the Defense for a clear purpose. Please don't do this, your Honor. I beg you. I beg you. Take the waiver and let the Defendant admit that he will not testify and waive his right, but nothing further should be said on the record in open court. May I have a moment, please?

13 (Discussion held off the record between the Deputy District Attorneys.)
14 MR. COCHRAN:

May I respond just briefly, your Honor?

15 THE COURT:

Hold on.

16 (Discussion held off the record between the Deputy District Attorneys.)
17 MS. CLARK:

Mr. Kelberg points out, absolutely correct, that all the court need do at this time is advise Mr. Simpson of his right to testify, that it is his personal right to Tuesday and to invoke, that he may testify over the objections of his lawyers, if he so chooses, and that if he declines to do so, then he has waived that right. And that is all the court need do.

18 MR. COCHRAN:

May I respond, your Honor?

19 THE COURT:

Briefly.

20 MR. COCHRAN:

There seems to be this great fear of the truth about anybody speaking in this case. This is still America and we can talk, we can speak. Nobody can stop us. The court asked me about Mr. Simpson and I respectfully indicated to him that he wanted to just briefly address the court. It is interesting at this length of time--and I don't want to sink at this point, I want to get the case over--we won't start the argument until Tuesday. But he has a right to speak with regard to the waiver and they can't stop him from speaking and that is what it boils down to, your Honor.

KEY QUOTE
21 THE COURT:

It also boils down to the court can control the orderly process. And all I am interested in at this point, now that I have been told that the Defense intends on resting and not presenting any further witness or any further evidence other than their proffer that Mr. Simpson understands his right to testify as a witness, that after discussing that with his lawyers he is making an intelligent decision not to testify.

22 MR. COCHRAN:

The court asked me about that and I indicated to the court that Mr. Simpson would like to respond to the court.

23 THE COURT:

All right.

24 MR. COCHRAN:

Personally.

25 THE COURT:

Mr. Simpson, good morning, sir.

26 THE DEFENDANT:

Good morning, your Honor. As much as I would like to address some of the misrepresentations made by myself and my--and Nicole concerning our life together, I am mindful of the mood and the stamina of this jury. I have confidence, a lot more it seems than Miss Clark has, of their integrity, and that they will find, as the record stands now, that I did not, could not and would not have committed this crime. I have four kids; two kids I haven't seen in a year. They ask me every week, "dad, how much longer?" I want this trial over. Thank you.

27 THE COURT:

All right. Mr. Simpson, do you understand your right to testify as a witness?

28 THE DEFENDANT:

Yes, I do.

29 THE COURT:

All right. And you choose to rest your case at this point?

30 THE DEFENDANT:

I choose.

31 THE COURT:

Thank you very much, sir. All right. Mr. Douglas, do you have a motion to move the Defense exhibits subject to redaction of various videotapes?

32 MR. DOUGLAS:

I do, your Honor. If the court pleases, good morning. We have a redacted version of exhibit 1104, which I would like to label as 1104-A.

33 (Deft's 1104-A for id = redacted 1104)
34 MR. DOUGLAS:

We have a redacted version of exhibit 1103, which I would like to label 1103-A.

35 (Deft's 1103-A for id = redacted 1103)
36 MR. DOUGLAS:

We have a redacted version of exhibit 1002, which I would like labeled 1002-A.

37 (Deft's 1002-A for id = redacted 1002)
38 MR. DOUGLAS:

We have a redacted version of exhibit 1102, which I would label 1102-A.

39 (Deft's 1102-A for id = redacted 1102)
40 MR. DOUGLAS:

And we have a redacted version of 1375, which I would label 1375-A.

41 THE COURT:

All right.

42 (Deft's 1375-A for id = redacted 1375)
43 THE COURT:

All right. Any comments?

44 MR. DOUGLAS:

Thank you, your Honor.

45 THE COURT:

Any comment?

46 MS. CLARK:

No comment on that, your Honor. We have an exhibit. I would like to substitute 527-A for 527 and I will give it to Mrs. Robertson.

47 (Peo's 527-A for id = substituted 527)
48 MS. CLARK:

I would like to mark the Thano Peratis tape as 615-A as the tape shown at the 402 hearing.

49 THE COURT:

The entire tape?

50 MS. CLARK:

Yes.

51 (Peo's 615-A for id = substituted 615)
52 MS. CLARK:

And I would like to withdraw 599 through 601.

53 THE COURT:

They are what?

54 MS. CLARK:

They are two of the planners and the telephone book of the Defendant.

55 THE COURT:

All right.

56 (Peo's 599 thru 601 for id = withdrawn)
57 MS. CLARK:

May I also ask, your Honor, for the court to inquire of Mr. Simpson, perhaps he would allow me then the opportunity, since he would like to make these statements to the court, I would like the opportunity to examine him about them. May he take a seat in the blue chair and we will have a discussion?

KEY QUOTE
58 THE COURT:

Thank you.

59 MR. KELBERG:

Your Honor, there is one other matter just for the record. The court had requested that I inquire on the People's position regarding staples and I had made the inquiry. It is my understanding that staples will not be a matter of consideration in argument, unless it is raised by the Defense in their argument, and as a result we feel that that will resolve the issue.

60 THE COURT:

All right. Thank you.

61 MR. KELBERG:

You are welcome.

62 THE COURT:

All right. One other thing. I am going to make inquiry of the jury when we have them out here. I'm going to ask them to contemplate the proposal to extend the argument, the court hours, for the purposes of concluding argument. And I indicated to you that I will make inquiry to change my plans for Friday, September the 29th to see if we can have a full court day on that date.

63 MR. COCHRAN:

May we address this issue briefly at this point?

64 THE COURT:

I'm sorry?

65 MR. COCHRAN:

May we address this issue briefly at this point?

66 THE COURT:

No. We've had our informal discussion. I need to see what my schedule looks like. I want to see what the jurors are willing to do.

67 MR. COCHRAN:

I was going to ask the court to inquire of the jurors.

68 THE COURT:

That is what I just said.

69 MR. COCHRAN:

All right.

Temperature

tense

Key Quotes (4)

O.J. Simpson
I did not, could not and would not have committed this crime. I have four kids; two kids I haven't seen in a year. They ask me every week, 'dad, how much longer?' I want this trial over.
Simpson's only direct statement to the court — a de facto proclamation of innocence delivered in lieu of testimony, exactly what Clark feared.
Marcia Clark
I beg you. I beg you. Take the waiver and let the Defendant admit that he will not testify and waive his right, but nothing further should be said on the record in open court.
Unusually emotional advocacy from Clark, revealing her concern that Simpson was exploiting the waiver moment for unsworn allocution.
Johnnie Cochran
There seems to be this great fear of the truth about anybody speaking in this case. This is still America and we can talk, we can speak. Nobody can stop us.
Cochran frames Clark's procedural objection as suppression of speech, typical rhetorical maneuvering to reframe a legal dispute.
Marcia Clark
May I also ask, your Honor, for the court to inquire of Mr. Simpson, perhaps he would allow me then the opportunity, since he would like to make these statements to the court, I would like the opportunity to examine him about them.
Clark's sardonic counter-offer to cross-examine Simpson if he insists on speaking — underscoring that his statement was effectively unsworn testimony.

Evidence (8)

Defense 1104-A
Redacted version of exhibit 1104 (video)
introduced as redacted substitute
Defense 1103-A
Redacted version of exhibit 1103 (video)
introduced as redacted substitute
Defense 1002-A
Redacted version of exhibit 1002 (video)
introduced as redacted substitute
Defense 1102-A
Redacted version of exhibit 1102 (video)
introduced as redacted substitute
Defense 1375-A
Redacted version of exhibit 1375 (video)
introduced as redacted substitute
People's 527-A
Substituted version of exhibit 527
substituted
+ 2 more

Notable Exchanges (2)

Marcia ClarkLance A. ItoJohnnie Cochran
Clark urgently objects to Simpson making any statement beyond the formal waiver, citing concerns about conjugal visits and monitored phone calls being used to launder unadmitted material. Cochran invokes free speech. Ito allows a brief statement.
heated
Marcia ClarkLance A. Ito
After Simpson speaks, Clark sardonically asks if she may cross-examine him given that he chose to make statements to the court.
strategic

Light Moments (1)

Marcia Clark
Clark's deadpan offer to cross-examine Simpson since he was so eager to speak lands as dry courtroom humor.

Objections

1 objections (0 sustained, 0 overruled)
Proceeding 7805 • 69 utterances
Criminal Trial
Department 103
⚖️ Start
📂 SEP 22, 1995 📄 Exhibits and scheduling
SEP 22, 1995 KRT DvH TD