📄 Jury instruction: Murphy's Law — Tuesday, January 24, 1995
📅 Jan 24 — Day 5
jury
Address:
C:\DEPT103\CRIMINAL\1995\JAN\24\JURY-INSTRUCTION-MURPHY-S-LAW.DOC
TRIAL
▲ Day 5 of 167

Jury instruction: Murphy's Law

Date: Tuesday, January 24, 1995 • Utterances: 1
Judge Ito addresses the jury to announce an unexpected external problem that affects their welfare, invoking 'Murphy's Law' as his framing. He is deliberately vague, stressing that the issue has nothing to do with the parties or anything the jury did, and dismisses the jury for the remainder of the day. The trial is set to resume the next morning at 10:00 a.m. with the defendant's opening statements.
1 THE COURT:

COUNSEL, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN, BE SEATED, PLEASE. THANK YOU. ALL RIGHT. GOOD AFTERNOON AGAIN, LADIES AND GENTLEMEN. THERE'S A RULE OF HUMAN BEHAVIOR CALLED MURPHY'S LAW THAT BASICALLY SAYS IF SOMETHING CAN GO WRONG, IT WILL GO WRONG, AND THE COROLLARY TO THAT RULE IS THAT IF IT'S GOING TO GO WRONG, IT WILL GO WRONG AT THE MOST OPPORTUNE MOMENT. SOMETHING HAS COME UP THAT INVOLVES DIRECTLY YOUR WELFARE, A PROBLEM THAT I'M GOING TO NEED TO DEAL WITH. AND I NEED SOME TIME TO THINK ABOUT IT, DECIDE WHAT I'M GOING TO DO. AND IT'S A RATHER UNUSUAL PROBLEM AND IT HAS -- I WANT YOU TO KNOW IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH ANYTHING THAT THE PARTIES DID. IT'S SOMETHING EXTRANEOUS, SOMETHING THAT HAPPENED OUTSIDE THE COURTROOM THAT I NEED TO DEAL WITH. YOU ARE NOT TO SPECULATE AS TO WHAT THAT MIGHT BE. AND LET ME BE FRANK WITH YOU. IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH YOU DIRECTLY. BUT IT HAS CAUSED ME GREAT CONCERN, AND I'M GOING TO HAVE TO TAKE THE REST OF THE COURT DAY TO DEAL WITH THIS SITUATION. SO WE'RE GOING TO STAND IN RECESS AT THIS POINT AS FAR AS YOU ARE CONCERNED. WE WILL RESUME WITH YOU, THE JURY, WITH THE DEFENDANT'S OPENING STATEMENTS TOMORROW MORNING AT 10:00 O'CLOCK.

Temperature

tense

Key Quotes (3)

Lance A. Ito
There's a rule of human behavior called Murphy's Law that basically says if something can go wrong, it will go wrong, and the corollary to that rule is that if it's going to go wrong, it will go wrong at the most opportune moment.
The judge uses a colloquial framing to soften what is clearly an unusual and concerning development, signaling seriousness while keeping the jury calm.
Lance A. Ito
It has nothing to do with anything that the parties did. It's something extraneous, something that happened outside the courtroom that I need to deal with.
The judge is careful to avoid casting blame or suspicion, while also explicitly instructing the jury not to speculate.
Lance A. Ito
You are not to speculate as to what that might be.
Standard but pointed admonishment — the mystery of the undisclosed issue makes this instruction particularly loaded.

Notable Exchanges (1)

Lance A. ItoJury
Judge Ito delivers a one-sided address to the jury explaining a vague but serious external problem, dismissing them for the day without disclosing the nature of the issue.
measured, deliberate

Objections

None recorded
Proceeding 4497 • 1 utterances
Criminal Trial
Department 103
⚖️ Start
📂 JAN 24, 1995 📄 Jury instruction: Murphy's Law
JAN 24, 1995 KRT DvH TD