Okay. Virtually every day, numerous times a day, trying to talk about Nicole and getting your wife back, true?
Often we didn't talk about Nicole but most of the time it was about Nicole, and Judy was -- she was like a shrink for me. I called her all the time. Okay.
And you also would call Nicole's house sitter, a woman named Giaconda Redfern, and talk to her about Nicole, right?
If I was out of town and I was calling like, for Nicole and the kids and they weren't around, I'd ask where they were.
I don't know Giaconda Redfern.
Okay. Now, there came a time when in April of 1992, you went out to a restaurant called Trieste, right?
This is the first time you had ever seen Nicole, in a restaurant, in the company of another man, not you, right?
No, I had met Keith. And she went out with a bunch of her friends, and I assumed he was just a friend of hers like all the other people that were there.
Now, after you left the restaurant that night, about 11 o'clock or so you went over to Nicole's condominium, uninvited and unannounced, true?
And as you walked up the path to the house, you looked through the window, and you saw Nicole engaged in a sexual act with this man, Keith, right?
As I approached her front door, the window was there, and I saw her head, and I looked and saw that she was engaged with somebody.
Now, after that incident, you met this Paula, and the two of you, you and Paula that is, began a monogamous relationship of your own with her, right?
And by this time, you're pretty much over trying to talk Nicole into the relationship, right?
Okay. Now, there came a time I guess several months later, into early 1993, when Nicole started pursuing you again, true?
Yes.
She'd show up where I -- wherever I was. She showed up at the golf course where I was, she followed me to Mexico, she made me cookies and occasionally -- she called my home and my office incessantly.
Thank you. That answers my question.
Now, Nicole was sending you letters and tapes and cookies and trying to get you back, right?
(BY MR. PETROCELLI) Now, by this time, we're into what, Mr. Simpson, March, April, 1993, thereabouts?
I hadn't even spoken to Nicole since two days after Christmas. I think I saw her for a minute on the 1st of February, and until she showed up at my house, I don't think I even had spoken a word to her other than maybe if I called and asked to speak to the kids.
Yes. I -- as a matter of fact, I know other than that one day I didn't even see Nicole for about two and a half, three months, and then I wasn't returning her calls when she would call to my office and stuff.
I think it's a little confusing here.
She was sending things over and calls and I wasn't responding.
Because I didn't want to deal with any of her problems. I told her if it was about the kids, just let me know. My housekeeper and my secretary told her. And I think I sent her a note or something that Nicole, I don't want to get into any of your problems. Because I had to deal with a lot of her problems and -- after we had -- after May of '92, and I tried to help her as best I can, but I was in my own relationship and I didn't want to deal with any of hers and I -- I just, you know, I just didn't want to deal with anything outside of the children.
And at the end -- well, let me ask you this: First of all, this is a letter from Nicole to you, right?
Well, she told -- the day she gave me the letter -- well, basically that's what the letter says, yes.
At some point you told Paula Barbieri that you were going to end your relationship with her and you were going to get back with Nicole, right?
Roughly -- probably two months, possibly a little more after she showed up with this letter, yes.
Okay. And you and Nicole began what we -- what you called the reconciliation period, right?
I gave her -- I said I would give it a year. She had a concern at one point that if we argued, that I would just stop, and I said okay, I'll give it a year.
I told her a few other things about one particular friend of hers I wouldn't socialize with and I don't -- and one or two other little things.
No, that -- that's how I felt, I'll give it a year, I'll work as hard as I can for a year, and if it works in a year we'll remarry, if it didn't work in a year, it wouldn't work.
When we were dating it was monogamous. You have to understand, I lived in New York, she lived here. I -- she never asked me what I was doing, I never asked her what she was doing.
The ground rules were you would date each other exclusively, not move in, and try to see if you could put your marriage back together, and if it worked within a year, then she would move back to Rockingham and the two of you would get remarried and be a family again, is that a fair description of the arrangement?
Basically, basically, but I -- she went out when she wasn't with me and I went out when I wasn't with her, so...
Okay. Are you saying now that you did not have an arrangement with her where you would be exclusive to her. You would be monogamous to her during the period that you and she were attempting to reconcile?
I don't think we talked about it. I don't think it was a specific conversation we had. I think when we said we'd work together, it may have been an implied thing there that we would be monogamous with one another, but I think it was pretty -- I think it was certainly implied when we -- when we sat and talked about it.
So the answer to my question is you did not have a verbal agreement with Nicole that the two of you would be exclusive -- exclusive; is that correct?
Did you tell her -- did she tell you we will not date other people in the time that we are attempting to reconcile?
-- recall having that specific conversation, having -- saying that. I think it was certainly implied when we got back together.
I'm saying that I believe it was implied when we said we were going to work with one another to get back together.
I'm not asking you that. I'm asking you what the deal was, okay.
Now, you said the closest that you came and she came to expressing that deal is that you would work together, right?
I believe it was implied. I don't remember the specific conversation but I believe it was certainly implied by both of us that we wouldn't date other people.
I would say it went -- with the exception of two or three months, mainly because I kind of felt I wanted out, I would say it went pretty good. It didn't work in the end. I thought it went pretty good.
Okay. And you continued to have arguments with Nicole as you had throughout the course of your relationship, right?
And one thing that happened in particular was that there was an article that came out in the National Enquirer in the fall of 1993 in which it was reported that you -- that you had begged Nicole to get back into the relationship, right?
You got upset with her because you thought Nicole was responsible for telling the reporters or her circle of friends told the reporters this falsehood, right?
That one or two of her friends had, yes, because there were some things in there that I thought were a little on the money and I felt that the only reason the National Enquirer would have known it was if one of her friends had gone to it with it, and it really, really upset me.
It upset you because you didn't want to want America to think that you were begging another woman, correct?
I didn't want an inaccurate thing to be written in the paper, and I didn't think it was right that one of her friends would go to a tabloid and make any characterizations about anything that was going on between Nicole and I.
In this instance I would say no. In this instance I was upset that someone who purported to be a friend of hers would take --
You were upset that the country was reading that you had begged a woman to -- to get back into the relationship?
Yes. It was severe. Severe -- I mean you -- it certainly wasn't severe in terms of '89, which I truly thought was severe. I didn't think the '93 incident was nearly -- in the realm of the '89 incident.
The entire time that you were arguing with Nicole that night, there was another person there on the premises, right?
I would say most of my argument when the other person was on the premises was me venting to him because Nicole was upstairs.
Okay. Now, what happened that evening, sir? You were at Nicole's house, and you got into an argument with her because you saw a picture of this guy, Keith?
That's absolutely wrong. I mean that became a part of the argument once it began. But that's absolutely wrong.
Not -- no, that's not correct. I think I left -- when I left there hadn't been an argument. I left because I didn't want to argue.
Yes, on the -- I don't know if we argued. She made a point to me that I said I wouldn't -- I wouldn't leave if there was something to talk about, we would argue it out. So essentially it was her saying to me I wasn't doing what I said I would do.
I don't think so. I may have called as I was coming over and her phone was -- either it was busy or off the hook.
And then at some point you called back, and the phone was busy, and you could not get through as though it had been put off the line, true?
(BY MR. PETROCELLI) Okay. At some point while you were dealing with Nicole you tried to call her and could not get through, you got a busy signal, true?
And when you were unable to get through, you jumped in your car, your Bronco, your white Bronco, and you high-tailed it over to Nicole's; is that right?
I drove over because I thought she made a valid point, I shouldn't have left, I should have stayed and talked it out.
Well, there was a lot that happened in between that and the portion that you're talking about, but essentially, eventually I kicked the door, yes.
Not the glass. It was a glass door. But I -- part of the door was -- had been previously cracked and when I -- as she closed it, I kicked it and I think a piece came off it, yes.
No, because she was not talking to me the way she was talking on the phone. And before she got off the phone, she came back down into the room that I was at, which indicated to me, even today, that she obviously wasn't afraid. If she thought I was doing something, she would have stayed in the room.
And you heard Nicole being asked, are you afraid of him harming you? She said I got scared. Scared of him physically harming you? And she answered yes.
You heard that, right?
And you heard on that tape Nicole say I got frightened tonight. When he gets this crazed, I get scared . . . hit me. He does not look like himself, he gets a very animal look in him, his veins pop out and his eyes get black. It was more precaution thank anything. I just always believed if it happened once more it would be the last time.
You remember hearing Nicole say those things?
And it is true, sir, that Nicole expressed to you in the course of your relationship, her fear of you when you got mad and angry and enraged, true?
And it's true, sir, that when you did get mad and angry, that you would acquire a very animal like look, correct?
No, she told me when you get mad -- you really scare me when you get mad. She told me that actually the next day from this incident.
Not that night. I will debate forever that she was not frightened of me that night.
KEY QUOTEWith whoever wants to debate it. I don't think her actions, besides the phone call, said she was afraid, she came down into a room that I was in, after she told the police she was afraid. I was standing there. I can't imagine a person who would be afraid would come down into the room that the person's afraid of is in.
Now, the police officers who showed up there that evening, the Los Angeles police officers, they told you that because of your celebrity status they wanted to keep this as small as possible, right?
Other than surreptitiously taping me and using it for their personal use, outside of that, I thought it was, you know, how they handled it, then I thought they defused the situation, yes.
Okay. So you didn't have any idea that the Police Department had told you that they wanted to take you in?
No. I felt it was wise that I leave. I was advised by my daughter and the housekeeper, you know, you're -- you're -- O.J., you can't be getting into a fight with this phrase that they used to describe this detective -- Officer Edward, and I just left.
No, they were never as far as I know -- I think Mr. Edwards may have walked on originally. After that they were never on my property.
They weren't where the gate was. But I have a wall on that side so if they were there, they would have been out of my vision, behind the wall.
Did you tell Michelle to go get Nicole, get her out of police car, and get her inside, yes or no?
Okay. Now, after this 1993 incident, you continued to see Nicole, correct, the October 1993 incident?
By the way, there was an incident the Christmas you went to the home of the -- the Jenners, right?
And then, at some point in time you saw this guy there named Joseph, who you believed Nicole had dated when you and she were separated, right?
And that upset you so much that you just got up and took off and the whole family left, correct?
No. There were some words between me and her that went for about a minute, and we went home and we had our Thanksgiving -- I mean Christmas meal, opened gifts, Nicole stayed with me that night, and everything was fine.
Now, let's turn to the 1994 time frame, sir.
In March of -- end of March, Nicole and you went off to Cabo San Lucas, right?
And as you said earlier, things were going pretty good in your mind, at this point in time, right?
At this point in time, I think for the first time I felt that there was a chance this was going to work.
And after that -- that short vacation, you came back to Los Angeles to get ready to go to Puerto Rico?
No. I came back to work. I had to leave on Easter Sunday because I had to start the day -- the next day on the job, and Nicole and the rest of the people stayed in the house that I rented down there.
Okay. Now, after the Cabo trip and while you were working on Frogman in LA, then in Puerto Rico, after this wonderful trip you had with Nicole, you're thinking things may work out for the first time, all of the sudden you got kind of a cold shoulder from Nicole, true?
Didn't you start calling Nicole from Puerto Rico and you weren't getting your phone calls returned, sir?
No. I called one day and she was great and I called the next day and she was weird, and I called the next day or she would call me and she was great and the next day she was strange.
And you started calling up Nicole's friends, Cora Fischman, Ron Fischman, Faye Resnick, and saying what's wrong with Nicole, right?
Yeah. I think -- I don't know if I talked to Cora because Nicole had -- had said that actually -- essentially that Cora was the cause of her erratic behavior.
You started talking to Nicole's friends, and even Nicole's mom about why is Nicole not responding to you as she had been in Cabo; is that a fair statement, sir?
Thank you. And you were pretty upset that having thought things were going to work out now, things didn't look so good, right?
And you came back into Los Angeles filming Frogman in Puerto Rico around what May 1, thereabouts?
Okay. And you and Nicole were having sort of a difficult time the first week or so of May, right?
I was, she wasn't. She had -- she had said she loved me, and she was sorry about the way she acted and she picked me up at the airport, but I, at that point, wanted out.
And you and Nicole had a planned date to go out on Saturday night and Judy and Lou would take care of the children and so forth?
Well, she wanted to go out, she got dressed, but when she got to the door she went into something I've never seen, she started shaking and she -- her words was, look at me, I'm having a nervous breakdown.
No, when she was shaking, I was hugging her and said, Nicole, what's the matter? She couldn't explain what was wrong and why she was feeling the way she was feeling, she just couldn't explain it.
And after Mother's Day, you and Nicole continued to sort of try to make this thing work, right?
That's not correct, but it's absolutely wrong that we continued to work on the relationship. It ended either that night -- I'm not sure, or the next night it ended, and I immediately -- immediately started publicly dating Paula again.
Okay. And it's not -- it's -- withdrawn.
Isn't it true, sir, that Nicole ended this relationship with you on May 22, 1994, not May 10, not at your instigation but at her instigation; isn't that true?
Isn't it true that on May 22 you went to Nicole's condominium that night on Bundy, correct?
And you, on the 19th of May, you had just given Nicole an expensive birthday present three days earlier, correct?
And three days later on the 22 of May, three days after you gave her this expensive gift, Nicole returned it to you that night, right?
I think the earrings -- I can't recall if I had talked about the earrings, but I hadn't just gotten them for her. I think that came up first.
Okay. And just so the jury understands, you had bought Nicole and helped design some earrings a while ago and they were stolen and she got insurance money, right?
She -- when we got back together there were some earrings I had made for her previously, and she said she had lost them, they got stolen, it really hurt her that she lost them. So at a previous -- I don't recall if it was Valentine's Day or something like that, I went to a jeweler and had the earrings remade, and it took him a while to make them because a few times when they came back they weren't exactly the way we wanted them. Eventually he got them made.
Unbeknownst to me, my office sent him (sic) a check. So when the insurance check came for the earrings, $10,000, my office gave the check to Nicole.
So at this point -- I mean I paid an additional 9 or 10,000 for the earrings, I should have the insurance check. I should have one or the other. The insurance check -- and she said she had spent the money from the insurance check.
So bottom line though, Mr. Simpson, May 22, 1994, you're at 875 South Bundy with Nicole and she returns the earrings, or you ask for them back, she returns the bracelet, and that was the official end of your reconciliation with her, true?
And if Nicole wrote in her diary -- in her notes that "we officially split up on that evening," you would say that that was false, correct?
I'm going to object, Your Honor.
There was supposed to have been a hearing relative to that.
Well, it was false. It was absolutely false. I had started dating Paula the day after Mother's Day -- or two days after Mother's Day, with my kids, publicly.
Publicly. We went to public places together, we were, you know, seen together, some of her friends saw us together holding hands. I mean it couldn't be any clearer than that.
Now, you were still publicly or otherwise dating Paula, let's say between Mother's Day and May 22, okay. Let's focus on that --
You were still extremely confused and frustrated and upset that your relationship with Nicole was coming to an end --
Upset, but I was -- it was a disappointment that we couldn't make it work, but we were getting along so well. I thought it was for the best.
Absolutely not, no. I don't think it was a frustration. Yeah. I think there was an element that the relationship had ended after trying for a year, but I think among -- I was relieved and I think among everyone who knew me, no one heard me complain and I -- I just went on. I mean I was --
So there was an element of being upset but no frustration; is that what you're saying, yes or no?
Are you trying to say to this jury that after all this time together, you were able to, boom, cut the cord on May 10?
I mean I still cared about her, but yes, it was -- it was -- I had no problem with seeing Paula and it had been public and, yes.
And so as of May 10, you were able to emotionally, and otherwise, immediately cut the cord with Nicole; is that what you were saying?
Wait a minute. It's argumentative. I object to him saying yes or no after every question.
I immediately cut any effort to reconcile with Nicole. I was happy to move on, but I was still very, very much concerned about Nicole.
Emotionally I was still very -- you know, this is a woman I loved, okay, I have always loved her, when we were apart we always said we loved each other even when we weren't married.
I still haven't cut the cord with Marguerite emotionally and I've not been married to her for 20 years.
You cannot tell this jury one way or the other whether you cut or didn't cut off your emotional attachment to Nicole as of May 10.
Okay. So then from May 10, until the end of Nicole's life, you still had an emotional attachment to Nicole, true?
And Nicole was extremely upset with you that you had missed that even though you had made every human effort to get out of it, right?
No. She asked me could I get out. When she told me about it, I was -- it was sort of late, I was committed to what I was doing. And then I called the people who were doing it, I called the chairman of the board of Hertz, I did everything I could do to get out of this, you know, important date that they had, and they -- they couldn't let me out of it.
Sir, it's your testimony to the jury that Nicole never expressed to you her feelings that she was upset you couldn't be there; is that correct?
She had told me previously that she wished I could be there. And I told her the problems I was having getting out of the affairs. I said I wish you had told me earlier so that I could have made some preparations for this.
Now, when you went back east to New York, you played golf on May 16 with a man named Frank Olson who was the President of Hertz, right?
And at that time, you told Frank Olson that you were very upset about breaking up with Nicole, true?
Okay. You told Frank Olson that you were thinking about moving to New York to get away from it all, true?
I already had a place in New York. I think I said I was going to move to Florida to get away from it all, which had been my plan previously, and my plan at this point in time.
So at this point in time, with the relationship with Nicole having come to an end, you were ready to move back east to get away from it all, true?
Yes. For a certain time I was going to move previously but I didn't move because Nicole, you know, wanted --
It'll move along a lot quicker.
Now, in fact, with Mr. Olson, you tried -- he kept trying to change the subject and you kept coming back to talking about Nicole, true?
No. He kept talking about his problems with his wife. That's what we were talking. We were sharing problems with -- with our relationships.
Okay. After you came back from that Hertz trip, Nicole, around her birthday time, had taken ill, right?
And you helped out a couple days by bringing over scones and coffee and going to Rosti's and bringing Italian food over and those sorts of things, right?
And during this period of time, May 19, is when she had her birthday and you bought her an emerald bracelet and gave it to her, together with a cigarette lighter, correct?
You told the LA Police detectives who interviewed you on June 13, that you bought it for her, didn't you?
Okay. And certainly on June 13, only three weeks after May 19, that is a lot closer time than today, true?
And in fact, you told the detectives who interviewed you, Detectives Thomas Lange and Phil Vannatter, on June 13, that you kind of were in a bad spot because you had bought the bracelet for Nicole, given it to her, she returned it to you, and you gave it to Paula and told Paula you had bought it for her, true?
It's partially true. But if you what me to explain it's a very simple explanation and I think you will understand if you give me the opportunity to explain.
Now -- and by the way, your lawyers said something earlier in talking about the accuracy of this tape recorded interview.
I just want to read from your deposition. Page 186, Mr. Baker. (Reading.) Question: Line 7, this is referring to the tape recorded interview that we had been discussing with the police? Answer: Yes. Question: During the time they talked to you in the room they recorded it, yes? Answer: During the time the recording was on, it appears to me that from what I can recall recorded everything that we talked about while the recording was on? Answer: Well, while the recording was on.
And what I just asked you about the bracelet was on the tape, and was on the transcript, right?
I will debate forever that she was not frightened of me that night.
Until this day I have an emotional attachment to Nicole.
Yes, I think she was trying to control --
I'd say ten seconds. I was a little stunned when I saw it, yes.
You heard Nicole say he's going to beat the shit out of me -- did you not? You understood that she was afraid of you when she said that?